Forum Topic
db73
MemberOvomorph01/6/2012I've been reading reviews of this new sci-fi/alien invasion flick. I can't find a single word in favour of this film, which I thought looked quite interesting from the trailer. It is being universally slated! From what I'm reading about it it's not hard to imagine why. Think Skyline with invisible aliens & set in Moscow & your probably about there.
But most worryingly of all I've just read in one review that it was written by non other than Jon Spaihts who, along with Damon Lindelof, also wrote Prometheus! Should we be concerned? Because the Darkest Hour is sounding like one of the worst sci-fi/alien invasion films ever made from what I'm reading (and I'm reading a lot!!)
[url]http://www.imdb.com/name/nm3123612/[/url]
[i][b]"The Darkest Hour isn’t a movie, it’s a sad, uninspired pastiche of sci-fi cliche surrounded by a dull, messy melange of lazy storytelling"[/b][/i]
19 Replies
Gavin
MemberTrilobite01/6/2012Ridley Scotts Legend - Minus the kick ass design of Darkness played by Tim Curry, that film is an abombination, yet he has also directed Alien, Blade Runner, Gladiator & Black Hawk Down (amongst others) and those four are considered top-notch films by virtually everyone.
Manndroid
MemberOvomorph01/6/2012I'll give you Alien, Blade Runner and Black Hawk Down, but I felt Gladiator wasn't all that great. For reasons.
Gavin
MemberTrilobite01/6/2012You get my point though - you can't win 'em all.
Take the other Lost guy J J Abrams - Lost (nope), Star Trek (meh), Super 8 (its a big version of the aliens from star wars episode II), and the Fringe (love that program).
Manndroid
MemberOvomorph01/6/2012I agree with JJ Abrams, though I liked Super 8 (for reasons not involving the design of the alien). Lost, Star Trek, Cloverfield... All meh, for me. Don't get me started on Joss Whedon, though.
Frantz
MemberOvomorph01/6/2012i did love Legend ... there are some scenes i can press the pause button and watch them for hours .
i did hate super8 ( great start and then an abominable list of cliches )
Serenity ... is embarassing .
i think Pandorum is a bit underrated
Ruth
MemberOvomorph01/6/2012I saw it (the darkest hour) on Wednesday. Uhm, it was a complete nonsense and crap, in my opinion.
+, I did enjoy Super 8 and Cloverfield. Just saw someone's discussing about it.
LHeureux
MemberOvomorph01/6/2012Pandorum was really really good. Didn't like the kind of Warrior-1337 girl otherwise.
Frantz
MemberOvomorph01/6/2012watch it snorky ..its worth ..yes there are some letdowns but the script is great ...i will wait your opinion :)
Mekja-Tek
MemberOvomorph01/6/2012If the best thing that comes out of someone's mouth during PROMRTHEUS is equal to the xenos were conceived by human dna and midichlorians(however you spell it). I'll demand my money and sue brandywine and scott free for me suffering anguish and torment for over 6 months. =)
Juxtapose
MemberOvomorph01/7/2012I kinda enjoyed skyline....i guess cause i was'nt expecting much after reading so many negative reviews....I though Battle Los Angeles was one of the worst invasion movies ever...bored me to tears...but thats just my opinion.
Cloverfield was interesting...the shaky camera annoyed the shit out of me...but at the same time I think it would have gone unnoticed if it was'nt for that particular gimmick?
District 9.....now that was an awesome movie!...
Gavin
MemberTrilobite01/7/2012@ Frantz - would you say its worth ordering from amazon
@ Jux - I agree about district 9, clever film and paved the way for the new Murdock
Juxtapose
MemberOvomorph01/7/2012....I hated the fucking a-team as a child (i hate it when a plan comes together)...the movie kinda exceeded my expectations tho...it was ok!
What is this Pandorum about?....have'nt even heard of it?
Gavin
MemberTrilobite01/7/2012I loved the A-team, and my fave scene in the film is when Murdock tries to defibrillate a car (makes me laugh every time).
Pandorum, I don't really know, always wanted to watch it then forgot about it.
Frantz
MemberOvomorph01/7/2012PAndorum is interesting ....very cliche is some parts but its carried by a very nice plot ( with alot of twists ) good technical part and a ben foster in great shape . There are some let downs in the secondary characters ( the woman plain suck ) .
ITs classic SCI-FI that rely more on the plot than special effects ( that are indeed good )
BTW there is an horror gem that almost no one know and its called THE BURROWHERS ...that is a good , dark , gritty movie .
Gavin
MemberTrilobite01/7/2012£2.99 from amazon, I'll get it next week and let you know what I think.
Starbeast
MemberOvomorph01/8/2012Sometimes good screenplays can be poorly executed (insert example here). But sometimes average screenplays can be elevated to something special - dare I say it, the original screenplay for [i]Alien[/i] (called [i]Starbeast[/i]) was on the whole average. It took Sir Ridley, his team and serendipity to pull [i]Alien[/i] out of the doldrums and into an unparalleled plane.
I've not been convinced about Jon Spaights - maybe nor was Sir Ridley (hence Damon Lindelof). But you can trust that whatever the screenplay finally looked like, this director is the sort to change things while in the flow of it - usually to the benefit of the final production. Therefore, I tend to have faith in something good being delivered.
P.S. I read somewhere that Jon Spaights had distanced himself from the "Alien Harvest" script that's been circulating the Web - another reason to be optimistic.
Add A Reply
