Who created the Dinosaurs and other animals?
Prometheus Forum Topic
Garethvk
MemberOvomorphJune 20, 20121956 Views28 RepliesSo if the Engineers created us, who created the dinosaurs, them, and other animals? Easy, god. Well here is the thing. Our fossil records shows that Man has been on this planet for thousands of years. The cave painting in the film pre-dated the others by 35,000 years.
So, we know man was here then and that the Engineers visited to influence the painting of the caves.
Now, since the earth was a gas laden, hot mess, when life first formed in our seas, which took millions of years to become land dwelling life, here is my theory. The Engineers did not create life here, they simply helped it along. They took what was here, refinded it, and let nature take its course. Why in water? Easy, that feeds into the entire ecosystem. For the opening scene to be the creation of life on earth it would have to have been millions of years prior, and Earth would not be the scenic locale depicted. It was not very pleasant at that time according to all scientific research.
Other discussions started by Garethvk
Replies to Who created the Dinosaurs and other animals?

GavinJune 20, 2012
I'm looking at this from the filmmakers point of view...
Take your pet cat/dog - how many digits do they have on their paws, same as us. How many limbs do they have, same as us etc. etc. same goes for virtually all vertebrates including mammals, birds, reptiles and fish.
Look at the filmmakers point of view, this could (not saying it is, obviously) be a result of Engineer DNA...
While we have 99% of the Engineers DNA/Genome other vertebrates on Earth would have less but enough to explain the similarities all because of the Sacrificial Engineer.
CrabfartJune 20, 2012
Only they can answer this later and I heard that bit at the start was not earth...

shambsJune 20, 2012
Scott said that the planet at the beginning of the movie could be any planet and in the case of Earth is possible that the engineers caused the Cambrian explosion...but Does the moss is Cambrian period? someone can clarify this :p
CrabfartJune 20, 2012
Also scott said you wont see 'god' till the second part and it wont be god it'll be something sinister I think he said...

pSIJune 20, 2012
Everything in the film is a projection of an individual's mind and interpretation f the world, none of it is factual, if one takes a step to the world of allegory than some physical realm, perhaps some hidden truths, perhaps even beautiful truths about these very projections might reveal themselves to the mind's eye ? People are often averse to simplicity, that in itself may seem "sinister" sitting here in this time and space lookng into the future.


shambsJune 20, 2012
And definitely Adan and Eve were two lizards in the paradise :p
[img]http://i1271.photobucket.com/albums/jj636/skybeast3/tumblr_lg98l1uifs1qzewk6o1_500.jpg[/img]
amon raJune 20, 2012
Really! Lets just stick with the engineers and their imperfect human creations. And besides that's John Hammond and InGen work.
RichieJune 20, 2012
the diffrent life forms that would spring from goo on diffrent planets is never ending...Earth is just another experiment and from theri point of view, no big deal...
Mr.Yutani (Detective Hudson)June 20, 2012
@amon ra
I sense that is iapetus hiding under that ID...
PS: Evolution explains everything. The engineers are the more "Evolved" humans.
Mr.Yutani (Detective Hudson)June 20, 2012
The "Lizard Adapt" Theory suggest that everything evolved from lizards*, Thus also supporting EVOLUTION.
*Lizards also means dinosaurs; Birds were formed from the evolving lizards (dinos)
Hope that helps.
David BishopJune 20, 2012
I think the "engineer" sacrifised him drank a kind of black goo which decrypted his DNA and resolved it into a basic living thing like a virus. It may started life on a planet - even on Earth - , or merged with the life forms already there.. But still evolution and darwinism stand here.. They just planted something which can turn into an intelligent species one day.

shambsJune 20, 2012
The genesis of Prometheus can be:
1) Another planet (not Earth)
2) The Cambrian Explosion
But Moss is what appears on the ground?
BluesfoolJune 20, 2012
dude, life evolved in the sea from 3.1GA. The engineers created US and thats it. The thing to notice in the film is when the biologist said "going to ignore 3 years of darwanism." The truth is that was never ignored.
MAYBE the engineers created Homo sapiens because evolution of apes could only bring them to a certain intellectual threshold ;)

GavinJune 20, 2012
Most dinosaurs and most animals share many features with humans...
- two eyes
- two ears
- two nostrils
- one mouth
- four limbs
...
...
...you get the point, whose to say that most of life on Earth isn't (according to the film) derived from Engineer DNA.

shambsJune 20, 2012
LOL That sound like the Troodon hypothesis
[img]http://i1271.photobucket.com/albums/jj636/skybeast3/troodon-full.jpg[/img]

GavinJune 20, 2012
@ shambhala - LOL,
But the point remains, in terms of invertebrates, there is very little separating one from another exception for proportion and layout, so to speak.

shambsJune 20, 2012
Yeah but the invertebrate creatures as the prehistoric arthropod (trilobite) are very different from the vast majority of life forms...but maybe in the beginning of Prometheus we are seeing another planet and not the Cambrian explosion.

GavinJune 20, 2012
Sorry I just facepalmed myself...
I meant...
[i]In terms of [b]vertebrates[/b], there is very little separating one from another exception for proportion and layout, so to speak.[/i]
My bad

shambsJune 20, 2012
But surely the engineers were the starting point and maybe evolution did the rest.
BluesfoolJune 20, 2012
@Snorkelbottom ... lol bilateral symmetry is a thing of evolution not engineer DNA lolz.
I think we need to focus on HUMAN creation rather than other organisms.
Their DNA matches our, but certainly not a pachycephalosaurus XDXD
CrabfartJune 21, 2012
Hmmm I think it would be more of a recent and subtle change - after all how long have the engineers been around - surely over billions or 100's millions of years they would change dramatically - I mean look have fast we change! And because in the film there are clearly 8 cells and they are dividing as if to make a whole life form. And life on earth started with single celled organisms. And we know even fruit flys have 60 percent the same DNA as us and we can trace back most of the lineage from all these things very seperatly from us for 100's of millions of years! I wonder how far they actually thought into the plot and weather they just said we will leave it open so it could be any time from a few billion years ago to a few million - but I hope they had a sound 'real' theory behind it all : S !
Tha_PigJune 25, 2012
In my understanding the Engineers didn't create life on Earth (in the first scene you can see there was already plant life) They just introduced their own genetic code in the ecosystem and to tweak evolution into developing humanoids similar to themselves.
The probably did the same in different words with different degrees of success.

CyberdeathJune 26, 2012
[img]http://laughingatgod.files.wordpress.com/2010/03/raptor_jesus_1.jpg[/img]
CerynJreyJune 26, 2012
I thought of this too-
My honest first thought was pretty logical I think:
Engineer sacrifices himself on Earth, giving birth to DNA resulting in single-called organisms.
Thousands of years later they come back, and interact with Humans- until give or take 100 AD, when they decided its time to "create by first destroying."
Why are we assuming they waited for human life to spring forth before coming back?
Maybe they had something to do with Dinosaurs extinction, etc.
Also, Ridley NEVER said that it "wasn't Earth at the beginning,"
What he ACTUALLY said was "It doesn't have to be."
Anyone who's been to the Isle of Skye will instantly go, "Oh hey they're on Earth."
Anyone who HASN'T been there can argue about it till the cows come home. XD

donbJune 26, 2012
I could have sworn there is grass depicted in the opening sequence. Grass is a flowering plant and flowering plants did not exist before 65 million years ago - about the same time the dinosaurs went extinct.
On a geoligical time scale, 65 mya is basically 'yesterday'. i.e. approximately 98.5% of Earth's existence was before 65 mya.
Assuming grass-like-plants are an evolutionarily 'late' development, then the planet depicted in the intro is somewhat far along, like Earth, in its evolution. (A big assumption but.. if you imagine the intro with Giraffes and Hippos, you can grasp what I'm saying.. it wouldn't be "primordial")
CrabfartJune 26, 2012
@ CerynJrey 1. The cells are at 8 divides in the film at the end so that's gone past single cells already!
2. we have fossils on earth dating back more than 3.4 billion years ago so it kinda messes the thousands of years idea up!
3. the start was shot in Iceland :P ...
@donb Yer I cant remember if the grass / moss was in the film clearly.
There just isnt enough info yet to know this yet : ( ...I hope they got all the answers later...
Are you an avid Alien fan looking for a dedicated online community of likeminded fans? Look no further! Create your own profile today and take part in our forums and gain XP points for all the content you post!



