Forum Topic

Gavin
MemberTrilobiteJul-06-2012 3:37 PMOkay guys a simple thread from me for a change, kinda...
When David gets Vickers her robe we have the following conversation...
[b]Vickers[/b]
"ROBE...HOW LONG"
[b]David[/b]
"2 years, 4 months, 18 days, 36 hours, 15 minutes"
...excuse me 36 hours???
And another thing...
They come out of hyper-sleep on December 25th 2093...
...And Shaw and David leave in another Juggernaut on January 1st 2094...
...Thats a week, but we only see one night pass
36 Replies

Ravager, The Alien Queen
MemberOvomorphJul-06-2012 3:45 PMwell, there not on earth, so their days must be 36hr+ long where they are.... i think

Sky
MemberOvomorphJul-06-2012 3:48 PMmaybe that bot is counting 24 HR cycle and anything short is just added to previous.
Uncertainty is the only certainty there is, and knowing how to live with insecurity is the only security.

NCC 1701
Veteran MemberMemberOvomorphJul-06-2012 3:50 PMi say Davids clock was in bad need of a simple calibration ;
dont know ,,,i never heard it the first time , but the 2nd showing,, i did
( after reading it here)
,,but wait ,,,,,
watch the extended DVD, and it will have it corrected

allinamberclad
MemberOvomorphJul-06-2012 3:52 PMNo matter how complicated or creative, I don't think there is any way to get to a place where that can make sense.
And I very much doubt they would calculate their journey time based on the cycle of a planet they've just that minute touched down on.
As far as I can make out, it's just another example of sloppy.

.
MemberOvomorphJul-06-2012 4:10 PM...screenwriters... can't shoot them.. or teach them proofreading skills...

Sky
MemberOvomorphJul-06-2012 4:20 PMrepairs and makeup, l33pstick time for noomi is included XD
Uncertainty is the only certainty there is, and knowing how to live with insecurity is the only security.

NCC 1701
Veteran MemberMemberOvomorphJul-06-2012 4:26 PMlike i said ,,the extended DVD will be corrected

David 1
MemberOvomorphJul-06-2012 4:56 PMSnorks:
Well spotted. Lindelof doesn't know how to read the time either... he is always... LOST in time
[b]Ask nothing from no one. Demand nothing from no one. Expect nothing from no one.[/b]

shambs
MemberOvomorphJul-06-2012 5:17 PMAll this week is lost in the Bermuda Triangle ... Lindelof Rules: p ... but it sure appears in the blue ray

David 1
MemberOvomorphJul-06-2012 5:31 PMShambhala:
MAGIC.......
[b]Ask nothing from no one. Demand nothing from no one. Expect nothing from no one.[/b]

shambs
MemberOvomorphJul-06-2012 5:38 PMLOL David yeah and I remembered your Lindelof meme XDD (that of the rainbow) and btw MAGIC sound like a funny song lol Lindelost you did it again :pp
aircraftfixer
MemberOvomorphJul-07-2012 9:40 AMInteresting...
Perhaps an LV-223 day is a week of Earth time. Maybe that is why Holloway wanted to get started as soon as they got there- HeHee!

Sky
MemberOvomorphJul-07-2012 9:46 AMwell 1 week on earth equal to 1 day on ship? lol how that works?
Uncertainty is the only certainty there is, and knowing how to live with insecurity is the only security.
aircraftfixer
MemberOvomorphJul-07-2012 9:47 AMPerhaps it took a week to put David back together, actually make their way into another ship without mapping aids or such. And then, figure out how to program the ship, adapt the cryo-sleep chamber for Shaw, get fuel.. And so on.
Would have made the movie way too long...
But I'm not being serious at all!
aircraftfixer
MemberOvomorphJul-07-2012 9:54 AMIn our own solar system, Mars has something like a two Earth year long orbit. I don't really know about how long a Martian day is in Earth time.
I posited (humorously of course) that the rotation of the planet LV-223 takes a week of Earth time.
MAJOR jet lag!!

Gavin
MemberTrilobiteJul-07-2012 9:56 AM@ aircraftfixer,
as someone already stated why would they base their time on a moon they had only just arrived on? They wouldn't.
aircraftfixer
MemberOvomorphJul-07-2012 10:12 AMGeez!
I am saying that "they" ARE are using Earth time.
A "DAY" on LV-223 is ONE WEEK worth of Earth time- the clock they are working with. The Prometheus arrives before dark and the expedition goes forth the first time. The following dawn, the expedition goes out a second time. But it is ridiculous that "overnight" on LV-223 would be half a week of Earth time.
I apologize if I have upset anyone or seemed to use sarcasm. I intended only to play on allinamberclad's post.

Gavin
MemberTrilobiteJul-07-2012 10:23 AMOkay I get what your saying ACF but we still have the issues of
- David's 18 days, [b]36 hours[/b], 15 minutes. On earth we have 24 hours per day not 36+
- At most it seems they spend 2 nights/3 days on LV-223, which being a moon would assumingly have shorter days than Earth, so the reverse would be true - a week on LV-223 would probably equal a day on Earth.
Now taking into account all this and the fact that they were they one Earth week (7 LV-223 weeks maybe) even though we only see at most two nights, it just doesn't make any sense, at all
aircraftfixer
MemberOvomorphJul-07-2012 11:03 AMEureka!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I didn't make any attempt to address the 36 hour issue. But I will now say that IMHO it was just a blooper in the script- Maybe...
My whole point was that I agree that the time shown between 25 December and ! January didn't make any sense at all, and I was agreeing with allinamberclad's post. But I didn't come off as humorously intended- to make silly statements that would explain nonsense.

Gavin
MemberTrilobiteJul-07-2012 11:07 AMI hope is was just a blooper,
And yes the week long expedition doesn't make any sense whatsoever (I'm currently adding it to a chronology of events in the franchise - thats how I noticed it).
A pickle indeed.

RobJM
MemberOvomorphJul-07-2012 11:15 AMYou would have though someone would have noticed the 36 hour thing?? even Fassbender himself?? unless it's deliberate for some reason?
The delay in take off (maybe Shaw put David back together with his body?), you would have thought in that time the 'Deacon' would have found them..

Gavin
MemberTrilobiteJul-07-2012 11:17 AM3-4 days to put David back together again, with David instructing, doubtful, a few hours tops.
aircraftfixer
MemberOvomorphJul-07-2012 11:47 AMMore silliness, as indeed it would be ridiculous to take Shaw a week to put Davis's head back on.
Perhaps the "36 hours..." bit is a nod to the 2000 Ridley Scott film Gladiator. In it there is a line from Maximus to Marcus Aurelius stating that he has been away from his wife and home "Two years, 264 days and THIS morning".
What say you?

Gavin
MemberTrilobiteJul-07-2012 11:51 AMCould well be, either that or Ridley's going loopy in his later years lol
aircraftfixer
MemberOvomorphJul-07-2012 11:55 AMEh, but it just doesn't pan out that such an obvious error was overlooked. Yet another mystery, or other thing put into the film to make some of us crazy...

b5historyman
MemberOvomorphJul-08-2012 3:04 PMOkay people seem to be getting their knickers in a twist about dates. The Prometheus arrived at LV223 December 21st 2093. It's in big bloody letters at the beginning. Shaw and David leave LV223 on January 1st 2094. The dialogue suggests Prometheus lands later that same day. As for a chronology Snorky, why don't you PM me and we'll talk about dates. Christ knows I have a comprehensive timeline covering events of Alien etc. Yes the diting of the film doesn't seem to make events spread over some 10 days but we aren't sure how long Shaw was learning the ships systems before they left.
Add A Reply
Join the discussion! Sign in using your Scified Account to add your say!
New to the site? You can create your own profile in seconds!
* Signing in also removes ads *