Should we have seen the engineer at the start?

Prometheus Forum Topic

facebugger

MemberOvomorphJune 04, 20121216 Views12 Replies

I was a little disappointed to see the engineer at the beginning of the film, it ruined any potential build up or suspense as to "what was wearing the SJ suits". I know the trailer ruined any surprise by having an engineer in it but I feel it would have been a lot more tension in the film leading up to the reveal of the engineers if we had not had seen on in the first five minutes. Imagine in Alien if we had already seen a Xeno in full view five minutes into the film....ruined would be an understatement. I believe it was a missed opportunity. What do you guys think??

Other discussions started by facebugger

Replies to Should we have seen the engineer at the start?

Pier75
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

Pier75June 04, 2012

i think that if it is true the theory by which the SJ drinking the goo is the one sent to earth to create humans to give SJ an other "hope", they should have shown it at the very end, allowing people to understand better. Anyway,there are too many unanswered questions ....

centaurian_slug
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

centaurian_slugJune 04, 2012

Any suspense was ruined by the TRAILERS, personally i think the engineer at the start was ok, it set the scene. it was one of the best bits of the film. You want to start poking holes or start saying "would it be better if.." for prometheus, you don't have to try so hard :) >>"a lot more tension in the film leading up to the reveal of the engineers" they should have got rid of that scene with the head reanimation. that got a well earned groan from people nearby in the cinema when i watched it.

Promethian Man
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

Promethian ManJune 04, 2012

Too much revealed in the trailers, including how the Prometheus crashes into and disables the Space Jockey Ship.

Microsis
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

MicrosisJune 04, 2012

How long would you want someone to wait to see the SJ/Engineer? We did wait 30+ years right? I haven't seen it yet but I'm sure from glancing at a few reviews there will be bigger mysteries.

Mentos
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

MentosJune 04, 2012

I'd agree, I feel like the sacrifice engineer was a little unnecessary.

Drekinus
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

DrekinusJune 04, 2012

I was pleasantly surprised that we got to discover the Engineers right from the start rather than wait for the climax of the movie, or some sort of plot twist. There was no better way to introduce them, since they're the center of the plot. anyway.

TheNextLV426
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

TheNextLV426June 04, 2012

I think a lot of the suspense was taken away with the trailers. They showed you pratically every good bit from the film. Im not entirely sure showing the engineer at the start was a good thing either.

Kyzo
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

KyzoJune 04, 2012

The scene of the engineer dismantling his DNA at the beginning of the film was important as it showed our beginning.... How the cells arrived on earth I think there are far bigger things to talk about... such as why the hell did the geologist guy (cant remember his name) go crazy and kill multiple people? let alone the whole first ever alien having no means of gathering further dna unless we assume that their are multiple dormant engineers on all of the ships on the planet. Any thoughts?

CronoX
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

CronoXJune 04, 2012

The geologist was infected by the alien. When he arrived outside the ship he legs were over his head dude? He was real messed up. If by Alien you are referring to Xeno I am sure they were shown on the murals. It looked like it to me anyway. Which is confusing as hell as that like something to worship? I really wish there was more dialogue between the Engineer and the crew. They obviously intended to infect everyone on earth but why? Especially when the beings they create want to kill them?

SilverX1031
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

SilverX1031June 04, 2012

I just watched Alien Resurrection again and I think I know why there is going to be little dialogue between the engineer and the crew. It is pretty much understood by now that the Xenos are biological weapons that cannot be controlled no matter how you try. That being said, I think showing the engineer at the start is a good thing. It does not spoil much and we already did see the engineer at the beginning of Alien, albeit with a hole in the chest.

markweatherill
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

markweatherillJune 05, 2012

In answer to the question, no, and I for one didn't see the big humanoid and think, Aha, a Space Jockey. We don't realise until later that the elephant looking face of the SJ is in fact a helmet and not it's face! (But I avoided the trailers prior to seeing the movie)

Melkor
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

MelkorJune 05, 2012

I thought he looked good. William Blake-esque. Melkor [url=http://wp.me/p2tPJ3-1]My review here![/url]

Are you an avid Alien fan looking for a dedicated online community of likeminded fans? Look no further! Create your own profile today and take part in our forums and gain XP points for all the content you post!

Latest Alien Media