Alien: Earth and Alien: Romulus sequel news

Unanswered questions (SPOILERS)

Alain

MemberOvomorphJune 04, 2012984 Views6 Replies
In the trailer David said to Shaw "Tell me you can read this". But in the film (in french), this question is asked to David.... Have you noticed that ? Why the exploration team let David opening the doors ? Why did Holloway, as a scientist, took off his helmet, as he perfectly knew that its own breathing could pollute the air in the chamber ? What were the holographic SJs fleeing from ? Except from the one decapitated , where did the others go ? How can 2 people be lost, whereas they could ask the ship for the way back ? Why the biologist tried to pet this obviously pissed-off cobralien ? Has he forgottent the simple basic rules of caution when encountering a new species ? Why the probes did not track the worms in the chamber ? What happened to the lifeform tracked at the entry of the sj shuttle (1 klick west of Fifield) ? Did the probe tracked the SJ sleeping ? And if not why did it disappear ? Why the storm wasn't detected long before they decided to go inside the ruins ? Why David put that goo into Holloway's drink ? To what purpose ? What happened to the cobralien which sprang out of the mouth of the dead biologist ? Why wasn't there any quarantine procedures planned ? And why Vickers let the first time all the people come back since they took off their helmets ? How many people were killed by Fifield ? And how many died from the final exlosion of the prometheus ? Did Shaw knock out the two people (especially the doctor) who tried to put her to sleep after knowng she was imregnated ? Why wasn't she followed after fleeing and before the C-section scene ? Why the same doctor was found taking care of Weyland, just after the C-section ? Did she forgot that Shaw escaped ? Why Vickers wasn't attacked by Cuddles as she left in the escape pod ? Had she noticed there was a monster in it ?
User Avatar
Alain
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
Sorry for the slight mistakes btw...
User Avatar
Frantz
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
Why did Holloway, as a scientist, took off his helmet, as he perfectly knew that its own breathing could pollute the air in the chamber ? - its not that ...its opening the door that change the air condensation ...if the air is breathable and safe why not removing the helmets ? i fint nothing strange there What were the holographic SJs fleeing from ? Except from the one decapitated , where did the others go ? - there were escaping from monsters generated by the black goo , i think that is pretty clear How can 2 people be lost, whereas they could ask the ship for the way back ? - yup btw i dont think the 3d scan was completed yet Why the biologist tried to pet this obviously pissed-off cobralien ? Has he forgottent the simple basic rules of caution when encountering a new species ? -you have an idea of how many people die every year forgetting the basic rules of caution ?? why he did die on that route at 120kmh when the limit was 70 ??? Why the probes did not track the worms in the chamber ? - too little ? every scanning device have some minimum limits What happened to the lifeform tracked at the entry of the sj shuttle (1 klick west of Fifield) ? Did the probe tracked the SJ sleeping ? And if not why did it disappear ? - that is hair splitting huh ... Why the storm wasn't detected long before they decided to go inside the ruins ? - i think is generated somewhat by the changing of condition of the temple Why David put that goo into Holloway's drink ? To what purpose ? - to "try harder" What happened to the cobralien which sprang out of the mouth of the dead biologist ? - is behind you !! Why wasn't there any quarantine procedures planned ? And why Vickers let the first time all the people come back since they took off their helmets ? - why not ? they did alot of security scanning How many people were killed by Fifield ? And how many died from the final exlosion of the prometheus ? final explosion surely 3 ....by fifield 2o 3 ..dont remember Did Shaw knock out the two people (especially the doctor) who tried to put her to sleep after knowng she was imregnated ? Why wasn't she followed after fleeing and before the C-section scene ? - no one did know that vickers had a medpod there Why the same doctor was found taking care of Weyland, just after the C-section ? Did she forgot that Shaw escaped ? -i dont think is the same doctor Why Vickers wasn't attacked by Cuddles as she left in the escape pod ? Had she noticed there was a monster in it ? - cuddles was inside the medchamber ...closed ..growing
User Avatar
centrosphere
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
"Why wasn't there any quarantine procedures planned ? " Because obviously advanced civilizations don´t care about the dangers of biotechnology. If you doubt it I have a pile of dead Engineers that proves this point.
User Avatar
RobG
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
Here are my thoughts on your questions!!! In the trailer David said to Shaw "Tell me you can read this". But in the film (in french), this question is asked to David.... Have you noticed that ? REPLY - I have never seen that in any trailer - the question is always asked to David? Why the exploration team let David opening the doors ? REPLY - They didn't LET him, but as he was atop a ladder, how do they stop him, besides this is kinda the point with David - he is more interested in furthering his knowledge than the safety of others Why did Holloway, as a scientist, took off his helmet, as he perfectly knew that its own breathing could pollute the air in the chamber ? REPLY - Because Holloway was arrogant and reckless. This team is just a bunch of scientists, why does everyone think they are ethical and play by the rules? It was this same arrogance that lead to Holloway's demise. What were the holographic SJs fleeing from ? Except from the one decapitated , where did the others go ? REPLY - No answer to this; we did see the pile of SJs found by Fifield and Milburn, maybe they were there or got out some other way. How can 2 people be lost, whereas they could ask the ship for the way back ? REPLY - Because the film wouldnt be as fun?! I dont get why people keep asking questions such as this - if in Alien, they had not gone in the ship, not gon down the hole, not peered into a Alien egg, not brought Kane on board, would have been a very short film huh???!! Why the biologist tried to pet this obviously pissed-off cobralien ? Has he forgottent the simple basic rules of caution when encountering a new species ? REPLY - Are you an expert in encounters with Alien life - see above! Why the probes did not track the worms in the chamber ? REPLY - Maybe because they are not programmed to pick up that type of life - it picked up the Engineer as has similar DNA to us but the worms are likely very different - e.g. acid for blood etc. What happened to the lifeform tracked at the entry of the sj shuttle (1 klick west of Fifield) ? Did the probe tracked the SJ sleeping ? And if not why did it disappear ? REPLY - I think this was the SJ in hypersleep being detected Why the storm wasn't detected long before they decided to go inside the ruins ? REPLY - Again this is an alien planet - it may not have the same weather patterns as Earth. We cant pick up a tornado until its too late, so why should this be any difference - this is a science fiction FILM not a documentary ya know!! Why David put that goo into Holloway's drink ? To what purpose ? REPLY - Simple, he wanted to see what would happen and he despised Holloway for his treatment toward him. What happened to the cobralien which sprang out of the mouth of the dead biologist ? REPLY - We saw that, it leaped out past Ford and swam away. Why wasn't there any quarantine procedures planned ? And why Vickers let the first time all the people come back since they took off their helmets ? REPLY - Vickers isnt a scientist - the scientists didnt call for a quarantine, so she has no need to lock them out. When the quarantine WAS called, you saw how Vickers reacted How many people were killed by Fifield ? And how many died from the final exlosion of the prometheus ? REPLY - Why does that matter?! Did Shaw knock out the two people (especially the doctor) who tried to put her to sleep after knowng she was imregnated ? Why wasn't she followed after fleeing and before the C-section scene ? REPLY - Because its a film!!!! Why the same doctor was found taking care of Weyland, just after the C-section ? Did she forgot that Shaw escaped ? REPLY - Because its a film!!!! Why Vickers wasn't attacked by Cuddles as she left in the escape pod ? Had she noticed there was a monster in it ? REPLY - Because Vickers wasnt in the lifeboat - which was ejected first and what Cuddles was in - Vickers was ejected in the escape pod I do appreciate some of your questions but have to ask how you can enjoy a film when you question such tiny details!!! It is a film, just go with - if everyone asked all these questions, there would be pretty much no sci-fi, action, adventure films out there!!! They are all silly and illogical in some way!
User Avatar
TheNextLV426
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
I though the OP questions were perfectly valid and if it wasn't for such poor script writing we wouldn't be asking them. To answer them with 'because it's a movie' kinda defeats the purpose of having a forum where people can ask questions
User Avatar
RobG
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
@TheNextLV426 - yeah and MY OPINION is that they werent questions worth asking - debate runs both ways I am afraid and that is mine. There is so much nit picking these days - some of the greatest movies of all time are frikkin ridiculous and its cool because they are movies!!! If I want realism, I will watch a documentary. And my other argument to those who bitch about bad scripts....if you can do better, go ahead - instead of bitching about it, why dont you show them how to do it??!! There was nothing wrong with the script - by no means an Oscar winner, but far better than some of the other turds witnessed over the last few years. But you are entitled to your opinion and I will state mine

Join the discussion!



New Forum Topics
Recently Active Forums
Alien: Earth
Alien: EarthDiscuss the Alien FX TV series here!
Alien Fan Art
Alien Fan ArtArtwork from Alien fans! Share yours here!
Alien: Covenant
Alien: CovenantDiscuss the Prometheus Sequel, Alien: Covenant
Alien
AlienDiscuss all things Alien here
Highest Forum Ranks Unlocked
Thoughts_Dreams
Thoughts_Dreams » Neomorph
89% To Next Rank
Neomorph
Neomorph » Chestburster
97% To Next Rank
Jonesy
Jonesy » Chestburster
54% To Next Rank
auximenes
auximenes » Facehugger
30% To Next Rank
Love SciFi
Love SciFi » Facehugger
30% To Next Rank
Latest Media
Join the discussion!
Please sign in to access your profile features!
(Signing in also removes ads!)



Forgot Password?
Scified Website LogoYour sci-fi community, old-school & modern
Hosted Fansites
AlienFansite
GodzillaFansite
PredatorFansite
Main Menu
Community
Help & Info
+

Sign In to contribute!