Alien movie and TV series news website logo

What David actually said to the Engineer. Mystery Revealed.

Prometheus Forum Topic

sukkal

MemberOvomorphJun 20, 2012Pinned Topic68485 Views131 Replies
What David actually said to the Engineer. Mystery Revealed.

SPOILER: This is about the meaning of what David said to the Engineer. If you are one of those people who doesn't want to know, don't read this. These are the words that David said to the Engineer: ida hmanâm aî kya namrrtuh zdêêtaha. gwhivah-pyorn-îttham sas daatrr kredah.

And what does it mean? Literally it breaks down to: this man (is) here because not-die he-desires. life_increase_wish to-him you-(can)-give he-believes. And what is the best approximation of what that means in everyday English? What would the sub-title have been if there had been one? This man is here because he does not want to die. He believes you can give him more life. And where did this information come from? It was supplied by Dr. Anil Biltoo of SOAS at the University of London. Dr. Biltoo was hired by Ridley Scott to design the Engineers’ language, teach it to the actors who learned it, and appear on screen as David's language instructor. If you've seen the film, you know what he looks and sounds like. That's also him teaching David while the rest of the crew is still in hibernation.

The Engineers’ language is based on Dr. Biltoo's own version of reconstructed Proto-Indo-European. In the fictional context of the movie, it is assumed that over 5,000 years ago contact between the Engineers and humans exposed us to this mother language whose human "daughters" are now spoken by roughly 3 billion humans. Because of this fictional "real link" in human past to the Engineers and their language within the logic of the storytelling, David is able to communicate with them. One of David's features is that he knows all forms of human communication. Some of the words in "Engineer," as it was apparently commonly called during the production, actually have a recognizable connection to modern English.

You'll likely recognize «hmanâm» as "human" or simply "man." The verb at the end. «kredah» ("he believes"), has echoes in English "creed," which is a "set of beliefs." For those who are interested in getting even more flavor of what the language is like.

Here is the full version of Schleicher's Fable in the version that the Engineers would likely understand. hyewîs yasmâ hwælnâ nahâst aqwhunsâz dadrrkta, tâm ghêrmha vagam ugênthâ, tâm magham bhrrma, tâm hâmanam hêhok bharânt. hyewîs aqwhobyun vakta; mya kêrt xnutâya vizât hmanam aqwhunsâz uh-gnathâ. aqwhunz vaktantâ: kludh hyewa! kêrt xnutâya vîvîzdama: hâmanas patâsa hyewasya hwælnam swah gwhârmam vastram hyewîzbya hwælnâ nahâst. tod aklawa hyewîs agrâm abhogtâ. Apparently Michael Fassbender spent hours and hours committing the entire fable to memory, only to have the first line of it used in the film. Poor Fassy. Corroboration HERE of the translation.

Replies to What David actually said to the Engineer. Mystery Revealed.

Hey Guest, want to add your say?


Guests can only post text. Please sign in to add links, images, etc...
Scified Editor Logo

User Avatar
garboozle
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
I figured he said something close to that. But I think the question is why that would make the engineer so angry? Thank you for this post that helps so much.
User Avatar
synthetic_69
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
sukkal: Thanks for posting this information. You are awesome! geopap: So many "Alien(s)" fans have made critiques of elements of "Prometheus" in which they write lengthy theories about the motivations and meanings of objects and events in the film. You've done something likewise regarding the scene that sukkal has written about in this thread. I'd like to suggest a far simpler theory to the Engineer's response to David speaking to him. The Engineer himself is a member of a group of intentionally designed, organic based artificial life forms. The Engineer is woken from his sleep and is groggy and confused by what he sees around him. There are humans around him speaking a language he can't understand. One of them is shouting in distress and another human subdues her with physical violence. At that point one of the humans speaks to the Engineer in a near approximation of the Engineer's own language. The Engineer realizes that David is, like himself, an artificial life form and the only member of the human's party who is capable of interacting with the Engineer's technology. The Engineer initially shows compassion for David because he recognizes in him a fellow being but he then tries to destroy David because doing so is a means to prevent the humans from gaining control over the Engineer's technology. This is the simplest answer for the Engineer's actions. I've had this theory for 2 weeks now. For me the information that sukkal posted reinforces my take on the events that I have written about above. We truly don't know if the Engineers were in fact leaving their base to destroy human life on earth. We also don't know if a human or humans actually undertook actions that motivated the Engineers to make a trip to Earth for an "intervention". I have wondered numerous times if the event that inspired the Engineers to make said trip to Earth was in fact the launch of the "Prometheus". We have no idea how much time has passed in "real" time during the Prometheus' journey. I think that a lot of assumptions that people are making about the Engineer's actions and technology will be proven to be incorrect should there be a sequel to "Prometheus".
User Avatar
jrcjazzed
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
linguistics have traced the family tree of language to 3 threads relating to ONE common language. It dates much, much later than the Hebrew-which itself is an un-corrupted language. No language follows or is derived from Hebrew.
User Avatar
Cry Havoc
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
What David said: [i]ida hmanâm aî kya namrrtuh zdêêtaha. gwhivah-pyorn-îttham sas daatrr kredah.[/i] Roughly translated as: [i]These people are morons. You should have seen how bad they've screwed up in this movie. A bunch of them are already dead. And we just got here. This idiot here thinks of me as his 'son'. He's got a daughter he treats like an employee. I'm a fraking robot, for Christ's sake. He wants you to show him how to 'live forever'. Jeez. You and I both know that ain't gonna happen. Man, there are days I wish someone would just take my head and beat him with it.[/i] [Engineer smiles] No?
User Avatar
geopap
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
@synthetic_69 You are right, in a way the translation suggested here is the most orthodox theory, which follows a straight narrating line. If it is so, I will be disappointed, because I like conspiracies and complex plots. :) We all make speculations after all, no one is in the mind of Scott. @sukkal If it wasn’t for your interesting post, I wouldn't have become a member here to express my view on the film. Good info. :)
"... and the sea will grant each man new hope, as sleep brings dreams of home." Christopher Columbus.
User Avatar
sukkal
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
[quote=synthetic_69][i]I think that a lot of assumptions that people are making about the Engineer's actions and technology will be proven to be incorrect should there be a sequel to "Prometheus".[/i][/quote] I this this process will *begin* with the extra 21 minutes. I'm almost SURE of it. We've been given very little opportunity to UNDERSTAND the Engineers based on what we've heard and seen of them on the big screen.
User Avatar
Osiris
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
Great post....I felt it had to be something along the lines of asking for eternal life/fountain of youth. The question is really why is the engineers reaction so soft then angry. He also really gives them a second to communicate before going berserk. Alas these questions can be discussed or debated with no real proof until we hear from the film writers/Ridley. But still fun to ponder
User Avatar
sukkal
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
@Osiris — Actually restoration of some of the footage that has been redacted from the original theatrical cut might also help; even without further commentary from the writers/Ridley in my opinion.
User Avatar
amon ra
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
Almost sounds more like a mixture of archaic Sumerian/proto Semitic put together.
User Avatar
CULT
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
I've got more detailed info on this but I'm not allowed to say... (and that's what a sense of humor will do...) Bacon, Bacon, Bacon...
User Avatar
sukkal
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
Yes. What is the Engineer word for "bacon"?
User Avatar
promalien3
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
Wow this is fascinating stuff with all that deciphering of what david said....I actually didn't think about what he said and I think its pretty cool how they put so much time, effort and detail into the movie...thats what most movies lack....good job Mr Scott and crew!!!
User Avatar
Crabfart
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
Siigh I kind of guessed that - was hoping it was something more special :( ...
User Avatar
donnie8421
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
No SHi%T!
User Avatar
Indy John
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
"......What does make a difference is that David knew things would not go well for his human counterparts....." Yes.. knowing and then acting for some(to us) unknown purpose)..in an Alien language..no less.. David knows and can communicate in a Alien language...light years from earth,, Something is not right. Just look at the difficulties in understanding,Earth languages,,Latin can be understood,,but when was the last time you had a meaningful Latin conversation?? As others have mention David has more cards he is not showing....
Be choicelessly aware as you move through life
User Avatar
sukkal
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
@Indy John — Part of the explanation of why David can communicate with the Engineers is in the viral materials and not explained on screen. [url=http://www.weylandindustries.com/david]http://www.weylandindustries.com/david[/url] Module 8.4 :: SPECIFICATIONS :: Communication "David 8 is fluent in all known languages through a dialectic implant and can infer the linguistic components of entirely new languages if encountered..." While this is a rather convenient conceit, it is [url=http://www.prometheus-movie.com/community/forums/topic/5553]not without precedent even in our early 21st Century world[/url], at least in terms of seminal technology. It's also quite relevant that in the fictional context of the story, MANY human language are genetically related to that of the Engineers.
User Avatar
Gavin
Group: Member
Rank: Trilobite
View Profile
Yeah David can talk to water condensers too

User Avatar
sukkal
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
But how about water VAPORATORS??...
User Avatar
Indy John
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
Thanks sukkal,,for the David linguistiic information,,,and it helps to explain then robot's actions in the movie..
Be choicelessly aware as you move through life
User Avatar
Cyclonus
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
The expression on the Engineer's face when he responds to David is pretty surprising. Up to that point in the film, the Engineers' overall dispositions and facial expressions seemed almost godly, so seeing that look of pure scorn and contempt on one of their faces was pretty scary.
User Avatar
sukkal
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
@Cyclonus — Pray for the restoration. I predict that you'll be even more surprised.
User Avatar
Diplomat
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
(rutger impersonation) "i want more life!"
[IMG]http://i.imgur.com/gpC37.jpg[/IMG] ...when your marshmallows are WAY over there.
User Avatar
sukkal
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
It might be easier to actually get more life than to pronounce the [i]gwh[/i] in [url=http://masempul.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/gwhiva.mp3][i]gwhiva[/i][/url], which is the word for it. ;)
User Avatar
Indy John
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
Are posters that want to speak the Engineers' language? I hope that Shaw is a quick learner as she and David race for the next adventure...so she can communicate,,with the 'aliens' she finds,,
Be choicelessly aware as you move through life
User Avatar
Indy John
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
"...Pray for the restoration.." Many notes look forward to the restoration..added 20 minutes or so to the movie...and somehow the story will become clerer,,plat holes disappear..and all will be answered,, The more we hope foer and expect answers..clarifications.and better movie experience,, I thiunk we will be more disappointed,, Just look at the sheer number of threads,,,notes, at this site.. the 'restoration could not even begin to address the issue we think are important. Take what you get for this movie..look forward to the next installment..and quit burning so many brain ells on additional theories that do not relate to the story presented on the screen.. Hmm I wonder if Engineers watched movies??
Be choicelessly aware as you move through life
User Avatar
sukkal
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
There is NO WAY that "all will be answered." I agree with you on that point 100%, but I'm confident that more INTERESTING questions will be asked or *could* be asked. The more those things are the focus of our "seeking" the less the more minor issues will be annoying (at least for me).
User Avatar
Indy John
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
"... I'm confident that more INTERESTING questions will be asked ..." It is kind of crazy for humans trying to understand the infinate,,,, However your point of 'interesting questions'..is well taken and I hope they occur..
Be choicelessly aware as you move through life
User Avatar
Cup o' Goo
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
Joined up just to say thank you, sukkal, for posting the translation. I was very curious to know what David said - would be great if we could have a language guide as, or even more, developed than Mark Okrand's Klingon - outside of academia, that is. I imagine it would take quite a while to coordinate the language with a consistent symbol set and syntax (assuming it hasn't been done already). Again, thanks sukkal. Off to explore other threads.
User Avatar
Indy John
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
"..he knew from his readings and watching holographic representations of the Engineer in action what the response might be? .." David sure could have guessed(or information supplied) that the Engineers' reaction would not be good..How could it considerating the Engineer was alone..surrounded by humans demanding answers/action? In any case by David provoking the Engineers; reaction he got rid of several crew mewmbers .. Weyland(though I still suspect he survives in some form)...and starts thinking of an exit plan for Shaw and him off this moon..
Be choicelessly aware as you move through life
User Avatar
Custodian
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
what's missing in Prometheus is ENGINEER SOCIAL TRIVIALITIES ... they're un-people apart from a 'language' and 'art', there's been no evidence of Engineer-Engineer interaction yet. One pilot contemporary. One sacrifice historical. And don't talk to me about the hologram scene with four Engineers, what I remember of that there was NOTHING exchanged between them, no words, no touches, not even any little dolphin trills of personal space barriers. Weird.
2013 sci-fi horror novels 'Custodian' and 'Tandem' available from Amazon, B&N, iTunes etc...
User Avatar
sukkal
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
@Cup o' Goo— Thank you, and WELCOME! I feel it was very clever of Dr. Biltoo to use PIE as the basis for his work for this film. He inherits a lot of structure from 100+ years of work, and can focus more on the phonology that way, which is ultimately what is important for a movie-going audience. Most fans would not learn ‘Engineer’ even if it were as fleshed out as Klingon. The vast majority of Star Trek fans have not learned Klingon, of course. I think the main make-or-break issue for whether a robust grammatical sketch and lexicon of the language are produced and released or not will hinge on a green light for [i]Paradise[/i]. If Shaw and David are headed to the Engineers’ home world, then I would expect a lot of dialogue in ‘Engineer’ there. If Ridley makes it important in the future and FOX gloms onto that as a potential money-maker, then there may be something extensive done... If you want a full (but very technical overview) of PIE, I suggest you visit [url=http://dnghu.org/en/Indo-European%20grammar/]THIS SITE[/url]. @FreePlanet— This is precisely my primary objection to this cut for the theatrical release. I am hopeful that we will see them being less-un-people in a different version of the film. If Ridley decided at the 11th hour to de-people-ize them intentionally and permanently then there is not a lot left for me here in this franchise. I'll stop praying for the Restoration and start praying for him to have better sense in his efforts on the next [i]Blade Runner[/i].
User Avatar
Custodian
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
Wow, Sukkal, so sorry to hear that you'll abandon this 'franchise' just because it was INTENTIONALLY OBFUSCATIONIST, isn't that the role of Hollywood these days? TO CONFUSE and COUNFOUND the audience, not to enlighten and enrich their growing minds? to let them see the NAKED LUNCH moment when the nourishment on the end of every fork is revealed for the 'useless eater'?
2013 sci-fi horror novels 'Custodian' and 'Tandem' available from Amazon, B&N, iTunes etc...
User Avatar
sukkal
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
@FreePlanet— Please allow me to clarify. [quote=sukkal][i]If Ridley decided at the 11th hour to de-people-ize them intentionally and permanently then there is not a lot left for me here in this franchise.[/i][/quote] By this, I mean that if in any sequel the Engineers are not featured and elucidated a bit more, the franchise won't remain very interesting to me. I don't care about the hammerpede, or Spike, really. I'm not "anti-Spike", but he/she as an existential threat could never be as interesting to me as The Engineers, living forever, and finding out that that's not all it's cracked up to be. I feel that Ridley sees Shaw as having something to TEACH the Engineers, even if that's not about Jehovah; just as we have a lot to learn from David. It's very difficult for me to see Shaw teaching anything to Spike or similar, or learning a lot from Spike or similar either, unless Spike is a catalyst for a discussion about avarice and technology getting out of control. I don't need these things to be stated explicitly for me to find the *film meaningful, but I need Shaw and David and the Engineers on screen interacting with each other for that story to be in there at all. SOMEONE decided in this cut to REMOVE the Engineers speaking and therefore revealing more about themselves to the audience. In lieu of that screen time we got Fifield sucking on a very expensive bong and then turning into a rather boring zombie after Milburn (bless his Southern heart), had a bit more cobra sandwich than he could handle. Don't get me wrong, I LOVE me some good zombies. Truly. And I'll refrain from commenting on the oral in too much detail here... But, Ridley is better than that. At least the zombie part... __ More Engineers?... YES! Please! __ More zombies?... No Thanks. Please allocate that budget above.
User Avatar
BigDave
Group: Member
Rank: Deacon
View Profile
There are so many questions, the only answers we got are... 1) The Space Jockey was a Space suit that contained a race known as Engineers. 2) That these Engineers dabble about with genetics and can create and modify life and that they had something to do with the creation of life on Earth via the Sacrifice of one of their kind so his DNA would spread though the Waters and create the basic building blocks for life on Earth. We dont know 100% Why. 3) That it appears that either some of them visited Earth from time to time or indeed was stationed on Earth, up until about 2000 years ago. We dont know 100% Why. 4) That about 2000 years ago some or all of the Engineers based on LV 223 (or maybe based elsewhere) had decided that Mankind or Maybe even all life on Earth had to be wiped out with the bio Weapon Material contained within the Urns that are stored on LV 223. We dont know 100% Why. 5) That apparently LV 223 is a outpost that is used for testing and creating some kind of Bio Weapon and Storing such a Weapon. Its assumed this could be to be used on Earth but why? Then again it could be that this outpost was not just created purely to build a Weapon to kill off Mankind. 6) That the Engineers on LV 223 have the same type of ship that landed on LV 426 and that the purpose of these craft is to carry cargo that are mainly various kind of Bio Weapon (Urns in Prometheus and Eggs in Alien). 7) There is some connection between the Engineers, the substance that is in those Urns and the Xeno Organism. We dont know 100% What or Why. 8) That the Engineers do not come from LV 223 but a place referred to as their Homeworld. Thats about all we really know and been expanded on as far as the Space Jockey/Engineers and the Xeno in this movie.

R.I.P Sox  01/01/2006 - 11/10/2017

User Avatar
zzplural
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
@FreePlanet: [i]the hologram scene with four Engineers, what I remember of that there was NOTHING exchanged between them, no words[/i] They were gesturing and using words.
The most terrifying fact about the universe is not that it is hostile but that it is indifferent
User Avatar
MVMNT
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
@zplural - there's definitely some dialogue
User Avatar
zzplural
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
Indeed. I don't know how FreePlanet could have come to any other conclusion, as it's pretty hard to miss, actually.
The most terrifying fact about the universe is not that it is hostile but that it is indifferent
User Avatar
Nessimon
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
First off, simply awesome sukkal! [quote="centaurian_slug"]but now we have to know what ALL the text that appears in the film says.. every single inscription.[/quote] The problem though is, that though Proto-Indo-European is reconstructed with some amount of certainty (but not a great amount), no written source exist from the people who actually spoke this language here on earth. Most likely because they didn't have a writing system. The oldest form of writing system we know of is Archaic Sumerian which was used about 5000 years ago, but not near the area where most scientists belive the Proto-Indo-Europeans lived. So one has to assume (and probably most people have) that the written language is made for the movie, and we won't know more until the author of the written language says something.
User Avatar
SubsumeYou
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
Yet another favorite topic that has me going here first before anything else when I'm on the computer. THANK YOU [SMILE]
User Avatar
SubsumeYou
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
@ Synthetic 69, if it's the the word 'destroy' that troubling for you, then perhaps maybe the Engineer was intending to finish a 2000 year old mission of renewal on earth. Can you accept that?

Are you an avid Alien fan looking for a dedicated online community of likeminded fans? Look no further! Create your own profile today and take part in our forums and gain XP points for all the content you post!

Other discussions started by sukkal

Join the discussion!
Please sign in to access your profile features!
(Signing in also removes ads!)



Forgot Password?
Scified Website LogoYour sci-fi community, old-school & modern
Hosted Fansites
AlienFansite
PredatorFansite
AvPFansite
GodzillaFansite
Main Menu
Community
Help & Info