Thoughts after second viewing...

QueenElizabethShaw
MemberChestbursterJune 01, 20174369 Views15 RepliesI have finally watched the film a second time and was surprised by how much I enjoyed myself in spite of all the frustration I felt after the first go round.
My conclusion is that it's a great story, but poorly told. As a vehicle to deliver the story, I give the film two thumbs down. Music and visuals were excellent (except for certain shots of the xeno). In spite of the characters being poorly developed, I really did enjoy the performances. Pretty solid acting from most of the cast. I am still not sure how I feel about the idea of David creating the xeno. I do believe in spite of what is in the book, this is what Scott want's the origin to be. I don't think he realizes that to us fans, just because the pathogen may be ancient it's not the same as the xeno (eggs, huggers, big chap) being ancient. At this point I think I would prefer he fixed this and firmly established David as simply recreating it, but I don't know if he will. If he doesn't I've pretty much grieved already so I don't think it'll be a huge problem for me.
Ultimately my come away is this. If you only saw it once and it rubbed you the wrong way, you MAY feel a little better about it after a second viewing. I definitely did, though I will continue to harp on it's weaknesses.