Your thoughts on Prometheus
Forum Topic

Chris
AdminEngineer04/6/2011Let the community know what you think of Prometheus, what are your thoughts? What are your concerns? WHat are you looking forward to? What would you like to see in the film?
Post your opinions and thoughts here.
Predator: Badlands - coming November 7th, 2025
179 Replies

Indy John
MemberOvomorphJul-05-2012 10:41 AMYes,,this is a question on my mind as well.. In addition I hope there some explanation/look at the culture of the Engineers,, I mean they must have more to their lives.than a military lifestyle and fear.. What do the Engineers do for fun??
Be choicelessly aware as you move through life

Indy John
MemberOvomorphJul-06-2012 7:18 AMIt has been two weeks since I have seen this movie..but by reading the boards..and discussing aspects of the storyline,,well the boards sort become a life of their own ... The possible storylines are developing other storylines,,far from the original movie,,,
For me.. I am now ready to see the movie again,,just to get my feet on the ground..and make comments based on the presentation..not on building on theories..based on theories..based on what was seen in the movie..
Still.. it is interesting to read the possible storylines in the Prometheus world..
Be choicelessly aware as you move through life

osustudent20
MemberOvomorphJul-06-2012 6:59 PMSorry. I had written a whole lot on here and when i went to submit it, i guess i took too long and it went to the log in screen. Rather than write it all over again, I will summarize.
First, everyone is only trying to link Prometheus with the Alien saga. What about AVP and the Predators? The Engineers created humans. Why? They apparently visited earth multiple times after the creation, as different civilization form different time periods drew them. At the same time, the Predators were visiting and teaching primitive people technology. The Predators already had the xenomorph eggs and were using it to infect the people so they would have something to hunt. Perhaps the Predators are super advanced and they either created the Engineers to do their molecular/bio-engineering (as we make androids; and as someone said they all look the same and are all male so they are probably clones) or they found a planet of yolked science nerds and commissioned them to create better prey for them to hunt. The ship in Alien had a payload of eggs. Maybe they were going to earth to replenish the supplies as the temple in Antarctica seemed to be the only one left and they destroyed it and the predators were reduced to hunting only humans. Since the ship found in Alien didn’t make it, maybe the Engineers on LV-223 had to send a ship armed with a payload of black goo to Earth to create new xenomorphs for the predators to hunt. But, somehow the engineers screwed up and got infected. The Predators are bad ass and would probably lay waste to the Engineers so maybe when the Engineer wakes up, he is frantic and kills everyone and tries to take off quickly because he needs to get to Earth with the payload quickly before the Predators get pissed and start some stuff. There was a lot more in depth stuff I would have brought up in my first attempt to write this but again, I didn’t want to write it all over again. I just feel people need to really consider the timelines and not forget about the Predator and AVP movies and only focus on trying to link Prometheus to the Alien saga.
I would love to hear others’ thoughts.

Schenkenator
MemberOvomorphJul-06-2012 8:11 PMIt would be interesting if Ridley Scott opts to make the "Gods" who created the Engineers and rule over this universe to be more "Predator" than our idealized vision of God as benevolent overseer. Humans could be entering into the cataclysmic cycle of a terrifying intergalactic arms race being fought between the "Engineers" and their oppressive, warlike creators.

Indy John
MemberOvomorphJul-07-2012 8:46 AM"....fought between the "Engineers" and their oppressive, warlike creators..."
What role(if any) would the human race..now represented by Shaw/David....in it's outcome?
Maybe none because of their overall evolvement,, And the fact that we humans are at the lower end of the food chain,,well,,is hard to swallow...
Be choicelessly aware as you move through life

BrianPrometheus
MemberOvomorphJul-08-2012 6:49 PMI actually didnt like the film first go around. Seen it at midnight showing. Had so much built up in my head I think its my fault I didnt like it at first. Gave it another run and love love loved it! Went in again and watched it in an open mind and really enjoyed it. Noomi Rapace steals the show and I have fallen in love with her. She was actually the reason I wanted to re watch it. I knew I enjoyed her parts and wanted to see her again. Good thing I did, the film is flawless.
Ridley Scott is amazing director, knows what works. I went out and picked up Blu Ray player just for this film. I knew I wanted to watch it in a perfect picture and get all the extras I could. Hope they have a bunch of making of, and interviews like Blade Runner Dangerous days.

sb306
MemberOvomorphJul-09-2012 3:31 AMIve seen it 3 times. I enjoyed it. its nice to have some good sci-fi to watch. Instead of the garbage thats out there in recent years.
I would have liked the movie to be a little longer. Im hoping we get a director's cut on dvd and blu-ray. But its not looking good for that.

Indy John
MemberOvomorphJul-09-2012 4:48 AM".....I actually didnt like the film first go around....."
THat is how I felt after the viewing the movie... There were 2o..or so people in the theater and when the movie was over,,,just silence....as I and others didn't know what to do..so we just left our seats..
In contrast to 'What's Live Got to Do With It'....when this movie ended,,the movie crowd stood up and applauded..a movie..in a theater!
THe human in me wanted the answers,..ftom 'Prometheus.,,,,now..
Be choicelessly aware as you move through life

iBot
MemberOvomorphJul-09-2012 6:57 AMBringing the AVP franchise back into the Weyland Yutani universe will never happen under Ridly Scott's stewardship. The AVP series was the bas***d child of corporate greed - poorly written scripts aimed squarely at mass market, simplistic consumption. They were the pop culture metamorphosis of an epic franchise that challenged both the intellect and one's nerves. If they were executed with the same quality of thought as Alien, Aliens and Alien 3 maybe they could have been great - but lets face it - James Cameron, Ridley Scott and David Fincher are intellects of the highest order who apply themselves only where they can see it will yield an impact - and I'm sure studio execs would rather employ less expensive individuals to feed their money making franchises. Having said all that I enjoy McDonalds at times as much as a fine wine - so I am as much to blame for feeding the AVP beast, as my insatiable curiosity drove me to see some good old fashioned D-grade horror regardless of the quality. LOL!

Indy John
MemberOvomorphJul-09-2012 11:02 AMMarketing...Also when visitunbg Casinos..the AVP.game is present,, with the XENO(in the few games I have played) clearly the favored 'alein'. So Fox knows where the money lies..
If it was the other way around..there would have been a Predator.reboot..
Be choicelessly aware as you move through life

Indy John
MemberOvomorphJul-10-2012 4:47 AM"..... - and I'm sure studio execs would rather employ less expensive individuals ...."
In looking over the cast Gharlize Theron is the only actor I recognize at first glance,,,,I wonder if that was a budget consideration..
Be choicelessly aware as you move through life

Indy John
MemberOvomorphJul-10-2012 9:36 AM...BrianPrometheus
"I actually didnt like the film first go around.."
Before the first viewing how much had you done to prepare for the actual movie?
Wqas it a clean slate....or just watched the previews?
Also at the end of the show what was the crowd reaction?
Be choicelessly aware as you move through life

lionback
MemberOvomorphJul-11-2012 3:18 PMHi Guys, I was so wanting to be thrown in to a chilling visual feast that had people screaming in terror and running out of the cinema as in the 1979 ALIEN. Well I dont think I felt scared at all :( then there were no Aliens as we are used to seeing them...pitty, the crew did not care at all about each other and infact killed each other... shocked, I thought we were the goodies?. SOOOOOOO many questions and not an answer in sight. Now I read that the film intended to link directly in to the story of Jesus Christ... :) yes that would have been thought provoking and ballsy but they seem to have had second thought and played it safe. I do love the visual feast that Prometheus gives us but I wanted more monsters that attacked humans and less humans killing or trying to kill themselves or each other. I hope the second film goes for the jugular and stops playing it safe so the kiddies can come along with mum and dad.
didnt live up to the hype but skurts around the elements that made this series of film so loved by myself and millions of others. 7 from 10 from me.
Ridley Scott I think you have missed the points that made you 1979 film a classic of all time.....

Indy John
MemberOvomorphJul-11-2012 10:13 PM"... I hope the second film goes for the jugular ..."
The next installment must contain some more action..and end with some interesting questions,,,to set up a thought provoking 3rd part..leading up to Alien...
*Prometheus..
*Attack of the Human's revenge
*SJ's Final Trip..
*Alien
Yea I could live with that line up..
Be choicelessly aware as you move through life

Webby
MemberOvomorphJul-12-2012 4:35 AMWish I could say I liked it. I would put this movie in the same box as avp . Total nonsense.. What I would like to know is. Was the script changed to bring in more money from future movies? We all wanted a prequel. Fox could have used Ridley to do a prequel followed by a reeboot of the saga and used Ridley again. Then fox could have used Cameron to do a reboot aliens and then took the saga somewhere it should have gone.
Don't like avp myself and think they spoiled the series. Althought they are just a spin off much like freddy vs Jason.
I liked the engineers but just thought the movie felt odd. With alien I felt Rodley had captured a realistic feel for the universe it was set in. You really felt that you were watching a crew on a long haul coming across something terrible. With Prometheus it felt like you were watching a story written by some one. The movie was not terrible but it just made little sense. If the derelict craft on Lv 426 is already there and been there for some time why does it contain eggs and why is there black goo in Prometheus. The only answer I can think off is that the lv426 ship is natural xeno and the black goo is manufactured weaponised xeno.
The biggest thing for me is who done the cave drawings and why? Why would we know where the hell that planet was. We have just got sat nab but prehistoric man could draw maps of the stars. Don't think so. And another thing why draw a map to somewhere that had weapons. It just don't add up. Why does it appear that weyland knows more than the crew. David also just seems to be five steps ahead of everyone else. I know he is some clever machine but he just scouts about opening doors watching aliens play the flute and chatting to them. The scariest thing about the movie is this android. Not the aliens. We could have another cross over aliens vs terminator . Lol

Indy John
MemberOvomorphJul-12-2012 1:28 PM"... I would put this movie in the same box as avp ...."
I just viewed ".. Aliens vs Predator - Requiem.." I watched about 1/2 the film and besides the low lighting..and poor 'alien' visual..I couldn't find much else to like about this movie...so I just stopped watching...
If this AVP movie is a box then Prometheus is a Giant crate,,,,,They are not even in tyhe same entertainment Universe...
Be choicelessly aware as you move through life

Webby
MemberOvomorphJul-12-2012 1:56 PMThey r both garbage though regardless what entertainment universe they come from.

Indy John
MemberOvomorphJul-14-2012 9:10 AMMaybe the 'garbage' can be used as fertilizer..for the next series of stories..
There is someone..somewhere associated with RS that is reading each of this site's posts..They are looking to see that nobody has uncovered their next storyline...or searching for a storyline that makes sense to the human race in 2014.
An additional goal would be to plant possible storylines just to see what the Prometheus crowd thinks ..
Sort of run it up the flag pole and see whoi salutes..
Be choicelessly aware as you move through life

alienqueen1972
MemberOvomorphJul-16-2012 6:06 PMI loved how it connected the dots to questions on alien!I fitted the puzzle right away!!Loved this film will defitenly buy when it is released!!

oduodu
MemberXenomorphJul-17-2012 3:56 PMLoved the music
Atmosphere brilliant
Plotholes.......what plotholes ?
No attempt at overdoing special effects because it served the story and not the other way around.
I think its brilliant and will slowly became a classic as time goes by.
I loved the pace of the movie.
The holographic images of the engineers and starmaps is awesome.
But the best part is when the the pilot chair appears from the ground and you say oh that is what it does.
Brilliant keep em coming.
SubsumeYou
MemberOvomorphOct-25-2012 7:27 AM I just don't like the 'they begin in pods' idea or the 'creation of man'. I'm interested in where Sir Ridley Scott will present.

Betterthanbrew
MemberOvomorphJul-29-2012 2:35 PM Was one of the most beautiful films I have ever watched, but some clumsy mistakes made from poor dialog really just made this movie more like 8/10, or even a 7.5/10.
I really liked the story and the amazing cinematography, but some scenes should of been left on the cutting room floor ( the scene with Fifield ,Milburn, and the mutated worm, "You just wanna get laid" scene with the captain and Vickers)
The birthing scene was great probably one of the best things about this movie
I really would like to see more movies following this one even though there was some dumb parts, I really enjoyed Prometheus.

zzplural
MemberOvomorphJul-30-2012 8:58 AMI liked the 'wanna get laid' scene. Janek and Vickers both played it excellently, and showed wonderful facial expressions.
In Janek's position, I might have tried to get lucky, just like he did!
The most terrifying fact about the universe is not that it is hostile but that it is indifferent
SubsumeYou
MemberOvomorphJul-30-2012 12:02 PMIntriguing, beautiful, grim, depressing, bewildering, the parts that I judge are unconvincing and truly unauthentic, particularly, the Fifeld/Milburn/ hammerpede encounter is confounding. Please, eliminate such illogic demonstrations and strengthen the story towards it's ultimate goal of a solid visually told tale.

Engineering
MemberOvomorphAug-07-2012 1:00 PMI went and saw it again yesterday. It's well known that I love the film. I'm going to be honest though and say that I question my love for the film all the time. I ask myself if my love of Scott's work and the Alien Franchise blinds me in some way. I ask myself that and the answer is always no. I go over and over the complaints about the film. I realize some have merit, some don't and some are just plain BS. What I know for a fact is that the film has given me far more entertainment than most films. Especially newer films.
Each time I see the film I find myself discovering new things and thinking new thoughts. For example, yesterday during the scene in which a young Shaw talks with her father and he says that the dead man may go to heaven or paradise and that each person has a different view of what "paradise" is to them. Then I started thinking about Scott's thoughts on this. How before Prometheus came out it was first going to be called Paradise and that paradise would not be the nice, beautiful place most people picture it as.
Specifically Scott said [i]"Paradise has a connotation of being extremely sinister and ominous"[/i] All this got me asking myself things like "what if "god" and "heaven" are not what most think? Why do most think the things they do? I asked myself those questions and many others. Some people obviously have views and thoughts of an afterlife and heaven because it makes them feel better.
Anyway, I can't go into everything but the point is the film makes me think and I love that about it. I also can't wait to see Ridley's version of Paradise.
[IMG]http://i1161.photobucket.com/albums/q507/Engineering211/sig2.jpg[/IMG]

Custodian
MemberOvomorphAug-13-2012 10:28 AMFarscape was really 'nearly' quite a good sci-fi show, a little childish at times, but Rovhu was EXACTLY how 'this Alien fan' saw the original (ganesha) Space Jockey, elephantine (never forgets star coordinates) welded into place in his Juggernaut control seat, from birth(?).
[img]http://images3.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb57524/farscape/images/4/43/Pilot_Rovhu.jpg[/img]
2013 sci-fi horror novels 'Custodian' and 'Tandem' available from Amazon, B&N, iTunes etc...

raiken
MemberOvomorphSep-03-2012 4:56 AMI luv Prometheus, with all its sense of mystery, wonder and awe. Its very much its own movie, and I respect Ridley for this, he sensibly chose not to make the same movie all over again, as much as I gather many mainstream wud hav wanted that. Ridley chose to open up this whole franchise.
We all wanted to know whos is that humanpid figure sitting fossilized in that giant wired chair?? How did that ship get there? and what are all those eggs about??
These are all answers you just cant justifiably answer in 1 simple movie, at the sametime as give fans the regular dose of sex, action and scares. This is what annoys me with the divided feelings on Proemtheus, Im all for people having thier views, but there have been those who even consider themselves fans absolutly slating this movie, just because these answers were not given straight away, and this is not fair.
We all know if a movie is successful there will always be a sequel, Hollywood works on the basis that if a movie makes a certain number at box office they will always want a sequel and it doesnt matter what fan demographic that particular movie appeals to (e.g. scary movie series).
I seriously believe Ridley has made a film slightly ahead of its time, in the themes and Ideas it explores, and lets face it not alot of science fiction movies have even bothered to ever go down these routes. Look at the recent sci-fi movies of late, starting with the digustingly overatted Avatar, Battle LA, District 9, Skyline, War of the Worlds. These were all good movies but all mostly the same, maybe with the exception of D9 which was a really good movie and different.
Prometheus is a movie born out of a very simple horror story/film, but Ridley (with the great Inspiration and help from artist H.R Giger), really added some genius elements that helped build it into much more than what that film was originally intended to be.
I think mainstream will warm to Prometheus in time, and it will become a classic, I just only hope Ridley Scott is allowed to do the sequel and keep going in this awesome deeply intruiging direction.
Last note: when the sequel does eventually role along, It would be so nice if when the engineers race name is finally revealed, they are known as "Necronoms" in honor to HR Giger. The great under-appreciated artist of his time who greatly influenced the Alien series, because if it wasnt for his artistic influence on that film, we would have no "Prometheus" today.

mamab7551
MemberOvomorphSep-09-2012 11:34 PMWhat confuses me is the fact that Weyland himself dies in October 2004 (Predaotr vs, Alien) yet looks to be over or near 100 yrs old in Prometheus which is set in 2094. How is it that in 2004 he was aged at in his mid to late 50's yet 90 yrs later is still alive? Also, he made an appearance as his so called self to show Ripeley a friendly face when he appeared at the end of Alien 3, just before she jumped? Which by the way happened sometime after 2122, which was when ALien 2 was to have been when Alien 2 was dated.

NoXWord
MemberOvomorphSep-10-2012 10:20 AMYou are a bit confused indeed.
The Weyland appearing in AvP is Charles Bishop Weyland, in Prometheus we have Peter Weyland. They might be related, and they might not. There's no hint that they are or aren't in the same fictional universe.
The one appearing in AvP is a homage, tribute, quotation, rip-off, whatever you want to call it, to Aliens.
Ridley Scott will eventually tell us how the Queen was born.
Right now we have the Deacon; coming soon the Mercury, the May and the Taylor.
Add A Reply
Join the discussion! Sign in using your Scified Account to add your say!
New to the site? You can create your own profile in seconds!
* Signing in also removes ads *