Prometheus isn't broken!! (totally spoiler free)

Prometheus Forum Topic

Mungo

MemberOvomorphJune 05, 2012900 Views15 Replies

With all the mixed reviews I was seriously starting to worry that there was something wrong with this film, but don't worry its fine, everything is OK. You may love it, you may hate it, but there's nothing actually broken. It has a coherent story, internal logic, a fully functioning start middle and end. At this point I'm supposed to say "Its not perfect" or criticise some element to prove I'm evenhanded, and not raving fanboy - but screw that! Alien isn't perfect, but it is a fantastic sci-fi classic, and Prometheus has every chance of attaining the same status....not sure yet, my heads still spinning...which is great! My only advice will be to check all your baggage at the door and go into it with an open mind. If you try to workout how it fits in with the established universe as you go along, you wont be able to keep up with the (intentionally) fast pace. I saw it with four friends, and we all came out with big smiles on our faces!

Other discussions started by Mungo

Replies to Prometheus isn't broken!! (totally spoiler free)

The High Priest
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

The High PriestJune 05, 2012

Did you like the flute Mungo? Did you wonder what happened to 8 members of the 17 strong crew? In Alien I loved how we became intimately involved with the 7 different personalities of the Nostromo crew, and felt something called "character Empathy" Which characters did you become involved with in Prometheus?

private problem
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

private problemJune 05, 2012

my thoughts exactly .i wanted to watch a good sci fi thriller and thats exactly what i got ! :)

FREEZE!
Co-Admin
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

FREEZE!June 05, 2012

Not sure why you got a spoil alert, but your review was not spoilage. Going to send this into the positive reviews. Also, thank you for posting your review, it gives me some hope. I get to see it soon... Let's chat once I've seen it! Cheers!

[url=http://www.madmax4-movie.com/]Visit the Mad Max: Fury Road Forums today![/url]

shardy
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

shardyJune 05, 2012

i am set to see PROMETHEUS this friday night, i had planned to walk into the theater with an open mind after reading all the negative critiques of this film, i will walk in there with an even broader open mind i do hope, that i am in the group of folks that absolutely love the film, if not, then so be it. bit i am hoping against hope this film will blow my simple little mind away time will tell...

Slipp_Digby
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

Slipp_DigbyJune 05, 2012

Checking in baggage at the door is not something that you should have to do in a ground breaking distinct original film. That why I paid RS eleven pound to do that for me.

ShinobiX9X
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

ShinobiX9XJune 05, 2012

the high priest David, absolutely. He's very intriguing. He's the puppetmaster. And we just don't know what he thinks or wants.

Corporalhiccups
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

CorporalhiccupsJune 05, 2012

Glad you enjoyed it. I'm going to go see it again in an hour to try to salvage something from it. Really felt let down by it. Lack of character empathy is unforgivable for me. David is the most realistic character in the film.

Mungo
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

MungoJune 05, 2012

@the high priest. I have never had intimate relations with the crew of the Prometheus.

Mungo
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

MungoJune 05, 2012

@the high priest. Indeed I [b]did[/b] have a relationship with the crew of the Prometheus that was not appropriate , in fact it was wrong.

sukkal
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

sukkalJune 05, 2012

@The High Priest — I have not seen the film, but your anger and condescension are palpable in your response above. I'm curious (genuinely, objectively) why you feel a need to express your feelings with such vitriol? It feels to me reading this that you are ANGRY at Mungo for liking the film, and intentionally or not, you're using sarcasm to belittle Mungo's experience and attempting to rob him of his joy. Was that your intent?

sukkal
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

sukkalJune 05, 2012

@ShinobiX9X — I'm pleased to hear that. I'm already "involved with" David 8 just from the viral piece, and the mainstream critics seem universally pleased with his character in the film proper as well.

Jtmann
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

JtmannJune 05, 2012

I felt no empathy for the characters in Aliens(except for BIll Paxton of course) or Alien. I find it very difficult to care for character in a sci fi film, especially since we only have 2 hours to form some sort of connection to them. You want character empathy, get hooked on Game of Thrones.

Kronik
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

KronikJune 06, 2012

I loved it. I went in with no pre-conceptions, I trusted Ridley when he said there's no direct link to Alien, no Xenos etc. OK, some of the set pieces were cut to fast, but there were some creepy and disturbing moments... Fifield before he gets back on the ship was a great scene. Sure, there maybe plot holes, but that leaves some back story for sequels to fill in (I'm glad I didn't spend two hours being spoon fed). It seems to me that the nay sayers seem to have the loudest voice, which is a shame and why I think we should shout as loudly as possible. Prometheus II could go off in a number of directions which I have my own ideas about - but hey, I'm not a Director, so what do I know : )

db73
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

db73June 06, 2012

"There's nothing actually broken. It has a coherent story, internal logic, a fully functioning start middle and end." ??!!! Eh?! We're we watching the same film?!!

Kronik
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

KronikJune 06, 2012

I am sick to death of people who didn't like to movie highjacking topics like this. Please stick to your own dislike thread where you can vent as much as you like with your fellow haters. This part of the forum is for people who actually [u]enjoyed[/u] the movie, and would like to discuss the merits of such. I bid you good day.