Forum Topic

mrphew
MemberOvomorphJun-12-2012 11:23 AMHaving seen Prometheus on a second viewing (IMAX 3D again & the visuals are simply stunning), it's time for me to rewrite my analysis again. It's gonna be a lengthy one, so sit back, get a cup of coffee and happy reading!
[b]What and why is the lone Engineer drinking in the opening sequence?[/b]
In the first few minutes we see a primordial planet, possibly Earth. We see a giant humanoid, draped in a cloak, certainly alien but very human like. He drinks something black from a receptacle, soon he disintegrates and falls into the rapids. Under water, his body breaks down, spreading his genes and DNA, creating life.
The black substance or sticky goo is perhaps a life-creating dark matter that the Engineers have discovered or created. It is perhaps a powerful DNA accelerant, altering chemical of some sort. The aliens use it to create life on worlds that could harbor life like Earth and other possible worlds.
[b]How does the black goo work and is it dangerous?[/b]
The Engineers know one must sacrifice himself to create life that would evolve into humans, in their own image. And yes it is also dangerous- just as Captain Janek revealed in the final part of the film. Milburn got killed by an alien snake and Fifield mutated into a powerful zombie.
[b]Why it seemed that the Engineers wanted to create a biological weapon?[/b]
The black goo's purpose is a double-edged sword. It can be used to create life or to destroy- just as David puts it. The Engineers were planning to use the black goo as WMDs, unleashing on Earth because the humans will one day reach their location and discover the goo for themselves. In their lack of knowledge and understanding of the substance, they will be exposed and infected and worse, creating the monstrous xenomorphs.
But there is a possible reason why humans must die. It is the most damning. Throughout their history, the humans developed their own gods, forgetting their Creators. The concept of the human god of Christ, Allah and Yahweh is blasphemous to the Engineers. And 2000 years ago, they affirmed their belief by a so-called son of god. They even adopted a calendar system based on this belief. The ungrateful humankind must die for their unbelief.
[b]Why is there a giant head in the temple?[/b]
The temple presents a clue if any intelligent human could understand the writings on its walls. This is where they store the substance. The giant head is probably a symbolic structure to show humans how their genesis began, a religious structure if you will, for the humans to pay homage.
The mural on the temple wall may also serve as a warning or reminder that the Engineers' home world was once destroyed by these Xenomorph monstrosities and any visitors or Engineer must exercise extreme caution.
[b]What is Prometheus' mission objective?[/b]
This space exploratory vessel is intended to reach the home world of the Engineers as shown on ancients cave walls from prehistoric human civilizations. But they arrived on LV 233 instead, a moon that could possibly harbor life. Note the ship is named with a single purpose. Its benefactor, the old and fragile Weyland, desires immortality- he is afraid of death. He is determined to do whatever it takes to obtain any secrets the Gods may have and prolong his life. David is programmed to steal whatever tech the Engineers may have. The android is effectively playing the role of the titan Prometheus.
[b]What happened to the Engineers 2000 years ago before Prometheus arrive?[/b]
A black goo outbreak or Xenomorphs attack in the temple perhaps killed many of the Engineers before they could undertake their mission to destroy Earth. Only one Engineer pilot remained in stasis.
[b]Why is there no probe or Engineer rescue team to investigate LV 233?[/b]
It is possible Engineers from their home world, have sent probes and search teams during the two millenniums but they too were lost. Perhaps their home world is wrought by black goo bio-holocaust or xenomorph attack that many have gone into hiding or too weak to organize a proper search team.
[b]Why did the last remaining Engineer turn violent?[/b]
Awakened by the android, was asked to reveal the secret of immortality at Weyland's insistence. The Engineer then discovered (by placing his hand on the David's head) that this synthetic life form had stolen one of the ampules containing the life-creating goo. He also sees that the humans have become highly advanced, creating synthetic life-forms, becoming Gods themselves. The Engineer became furious by this sacrilege and thievery that he gave the visitors a fatal beating.
[b]Why did Shaw decides to head to the Engineer's home world and not Earth?[/b]
She wants answers. Having lost her partner and father, Shaw has nothing more to lose but her own faith. To obtain the reasons why their Creators chose to destroy their own creations and perhaps to satisfy her intuition that the Engineers are created just like [i]us[/i] by an unseen God.
Thanks for reading. I may be wrong but it's the closest thing I feel to making the storyline more plausible. Please share your thoughts.
14 Replies

Danial92
MemberOvomorphJun-12-2012 11:35 AM@mrphew
Nice 2nd review of PROMETHEUS, and some part from your explanation had answered my questions for it. Thanks......^^
I was more interesting about the sending of the engineer rescue team to LV 233 to rescue the engineers, if they really didn't arrive on LV 233 to save them, maybe because problems occured in their homeworld or they been flee to another planet without any reason for it?

mrphew
MemberOvomorphJun-12-2012 11:45 AM@Danial92
Thanks for reading. There are no visual signs on LV 233 that the Engineers sent probes or search parties after a long lost of contact for two thousand years. It is possible that their home world is no longer habitable which in this case will bear no fruition for Shaw & her android companion. If they could find an Engineer world, wouldn't it be logical for the aliens to probe LV 233 or continue their mission to destroy Earth?

archyboi
MemberOvomorphJun-12-2012 11:56 AMInteresting. But many holes in your view. If you're right then why did Scott launch 'What is 10.11.12?' Did you stay until the end of the credits of the film? The very end? It has a flash frame that the entire preceding footage is the 'Property of Weyland Corp.'
How would that be possible? Unless David eventually returns to Earth and the Company ...
You see much of the additional 25 or so munites that will be returned into the extended version of the film to be released 10.11.12, I'm guessing, would be a conversation between David's head and the lone surviving Engineer ... wouldn't you agree?

Danial92
MemberOvomorphJun-12-2012 12:04 PM@archyboi
There's a flash frame of the entire preceding footage is from Weyland being shown at the very end of the film? How came I miss that out???

mrphew
MemberOvomorphJun-12-2012 12:07 PM@archyboi
Thanks for reading. It is possible the ship Prometheus had sent transmissions back to Earth but as shown in the film, they did not get any responses. Perhaps Weyland Corp has been monitoring their activities right from the start of their journey, only the old man and the android are privy to the information.
The question that David put forward to the last remaining Engineer is the biggest mystery the film is projecting. It seems the screenwriters and the director may seemed intent to keeping it 'only to David's knowledge' and providing only alien language rather than its actual meaning. I may be wrong- let us wait in the coming months and see for ourselves.

archyboi
MemberOvomorphJun-12-2012 11:24 PMWe'll see won't we ... mrphew.
What I'm intrigued with that no one seems to be talking about is the following. The opening sequence is a dark retake on Nicholas Meyer's [i]Star Trek II: The Wrath of Kahn[/i]'s Project Genesis. That's interesting. Scott is remoulded it into Weyland Corp's Project Genesis. I don't think this is an accident. It's intentional. In the Project Prometheus files are posted Shaw's Notes. One of them is a sketch depicting Zeta Reticuli Binary and adjacent star systems form archaeological picto-pecto-graphic sources. Have you seen it? You should if not. It's Betty and Barney Hill's Abduction experience Star Map that Betty draws under hypnosis! Check it. It is. By this reckoning Zeta Reticuli II LV-223 is 37 light years away. 2 years, 4 months and change to go 37 light years. Anthropogenic FTL technology is in its nascent developmental stage. How does David know the Engineer is coming for Shaw? He had a conversation of course -- that will be very interesting. I'm guessing this is the connection to Nietzsche's [i]Also Spracht Zarathustra[/i] on What is 10.11.12. Thus spake Superman, indeed, yes?
Yes, Danial92, it was cool. Says: 'The Entire Preceding Footage is Property of Weyland Corp. Go to 'What is 10.11.12?'' It's a marketing ploy but it's a clever marketing ploy that has me hooked.

mrphew
MemberOvomorphJun-13-2012 3:41 AMIn an email [url=http://io9.com/5917448/all-of-your-lingering-prometheus-questions-answered?tag=prometheus]interview[/url] between MTV News & screenwriter Damon Lindelof wrote:
Yes. David's dialogue with the Engineer has an English translation, but Ridley felt very strongly about not subtitling it. I spoke at length about this on my DVD commentary.
Also, it is also a very interesting conjecture that David might've spoken to the Engineer after the alien ship ran aground. Even more tantalizing if we knew what transpired between them.

archyboi
MemberOvomorphJun-13-2012 10:02 AMThat's all I'm saying.
Now on to more important matters. You didn't respond to my observations but I'm most interested in hearing your comments regarding the [i]Star Trek II[/i] Project Genesis, Betty & Barney Hill UFO Abduction Star Map, and Nietszche connections. These are fascinating.
As for your 'transmission' hypothesis, it's unfortunately not credible. In the only universe in which we live the Einsteinian Light Speed Limit is absolute. There are two problems for SF screenwriters and directors. The only means to an FTL technology is the unleashing of heretofore unobtainable energy converstion on the Einsteinian scale: [i]E[/i] = [i]mc[/i]2. Even then, theorists have determined that the amount of energy required to produce a viable spacetime warp bubble surrounding a ship so it can 'surf' so-called 'normal' spacetime effectively permitting FTL travel is roughly 10 Billion times greater than the total energy of the known universe. Problematic.
Ridley gets around this by doing two things upon which I'm willing to suspend belief. One, he stipulates that an ion-drive would necessitate a long transit time period between destinations in the local intra-galactic group of star systems. This solves the fuel/distance problem but not the speed problem. As we know from the Hill/Fish Star Map and Scott Zeta Reticuli II LV-223 is 37 lightyears away. That makes an approximate 40-year transit period. Scott says it's 2 years, 4 months and change. OK, I'll suspend belief on that. Second, an ion-drive technique is NOT true FTL -- it's reaction sublight. OK, I'll suspend belief on that too.
Now to your problem. In this universe all EM-driven remote communications are subject to the Einsteinian Light Speed Limit. This would be a highly impractical and useless mode of communications bewteen star systems, particularly in a colonization scenario. All we have to do is look to Britain for a solution in this context. The Weyland fleets of star transports would serve very like the monarchical Royal Mail Ship system beginning in the late 16th on into the early 20th centuries. Starships would be equiped and protocoled for hard-/software discrete secured communications data packages or commpaks in a web of interstellar commpaks transportation. Therefore when USCSS [i]Prometheus[/i] rammed [i]Juggernaut I[/i] and scuttled itself all of its data was destroyed too, preventing receipt and collation at Earth or more importantly Weyland Corp Headquarters. If tramissions were sent they'd take 37 years to reach Earth. Which is VERY interesting because this is perhaps why Weyland Corp doesn't send USCSS [i]Nostromo[/i] commercial towing vessel to Zeta Reticuli I LV-426 until, wait for it; approximately 40 years later. But this doesn't tell us yet how the intel on LV-426 was gathered.
Now, let's dispense with so-called 'subspace communications.' This is merely a bad TV [i]deus ex machina[/i] cliche from Gene Roddenberry's [i]Star Trek[/i] which he stole from Fred McLeod Wilcox's 1956 [i]Forbidden Planet[/i]. Really? 'Short-circuiting the spacetime continuum on the parsec level'??? Ridiculous.
What interests me about Scott's Weyland Corp Project Genesis is its direct connection to a line of Spock's in [i]Star Trek II[/i] in response to McCoy's query, 'What if it was used on an inhabited planet.' 'Why, it would replace the existing matrix in favor of its new matrix, Doctor.'
This is precisely what we witnessed in the opening sequence of [i]Prometheus[/i] -- down to the breakdown/deconstruction of the Sacrificial Engineer's DNA and eventual replacement/reconstruction in favor of the new Engineer Bio-Former matrix. Voila. Neo-seeded Earth in the image of our makers, the Engineers. As Spock would say, fascinating.

archyboi
MemberOvomorphJun-13-2012 10:10 AMI forgot something. In [i]Star Trek II[/i] it's called by Dr.s Marcus 'The Genesis Effect.'
Genesis Effect, indeed. That's the opening sequence of [i]Prometheus[/i]. Scott is pretty brilliant and he knows his SF lore and mythology. Which BTW is our new mythology for our time. Connecting it up with Greek Mythology is a stroke of genius.

archyboi
MemberOvomorphJun-13-2012 10:34 AMJust to be on the same page here. 37 lightyears = 222 TRILLION miles or 357 TRILLION kilometers. Not Vickers really stupid remark about traveling half a billion miles to find a man. Although, maybe Scott is being really cagey and highlighting the braindeadedness of nepotistic corporate shills. I must say I'm inclined towards the latter.

mrphew
MemberOvomorphJun-25-2012 11:28 PMI think the screenwriters allowed some real 'science fiction' to justify technological feats like FTL space travel or interstellar communications. I remember in Alien, the crew in Nostromo tried to contact Antarctica mission control prior to discovering LV-426.
The more we delve into Prometheus we realize for many of us here, it opens a plethora of discussions, ideas and insights. I suspect this is the director's intent and he has succeeded exceedingly well here.

Tha_Pig
MemberOvomorphJun-26-2012 1:06 AMI think the explanation of why the awakened engineer becomes violent is easy. He has been sleeping for 2000 years, so for him the catastrophic events that killed all his friends happened a moment ago.
From his point of view, a biological experiment went terribly wrong and he was the only one lucky enough to lock himself in a hibernation chamber while the rest of the crew got massacred.
Now he is awakened by the creatures his race used as lab rats long time ago. He knows they share the same DNA that caused the accident. He probably also knows if his DNA and the one of humans get combined the result will be an unstoppable killing machine (the so called Xenomorph)
His only logical reaction would be to try to kill he humans, which from his point of view are just another dangerous experiment subject that went out of hand.

mrphew
MemberOvomorphJun-26-2012 1:28 AM@Tha_Pig I agree there are valid points in your opinion. But let us look at the central theme of the movie- Prometheus. The ship was named for single purpose for the act of stealing something from the gods. It could've been named Voyager, Pilgrim or whatnot but it is named such.
I do believe, aside from anger and harsh quarantine measures (beating the crap of the human visitors), Baldy taught them a lesson not to steal from them ever again.
Add A Reply