Alien: Earth and Alien: Romulus sequel news

We know how it crashes, but how does a Derelict land?!

Prometheus Forum Topic

Starbeast

MemberOvomorphJanuary 17, 20122097 Views24 Replies
Okay so I don't think anyone here has yet argued that the Derelict in both Alien and Prometheus does [i]not[/i] crash land. Afterall, in Alien and Aliens it looks like it's toppled over and also ruptured, and in Prometheus it descents after an explosion caused by a possible collision mid-air. But suddenly I just thought, "wait a minute, what if in one of the two films, the Derelict is in fact landed in the correct position?" For me, in the Prometheus 'crash', surely it is far more difficult for the ship to crash upright as it were than it is to come down, wobble around, and fall flat on its face? We can all try it with any coin in your pocket - I bet none come to rest edge on... Right? I'm now more leaning towards the ship doing an emergency landing which also happens to be the correct landing position, hence the not too much damage to the ship (debris is from the collided impacter) - now ok we don't see any landing gear or equivalent but maybe that's just alien technology for you. However... Although this theory pleases and satisfies me, ironically it's the Derelict in Alien which provide a counter argument: the end state of the Alien Derelict is not edge on but more slanted like its fallen on its back. It looks crashed to the human eye but perhaps this one is not crashed but landed as best it could. And the reason I raise this is because of the cockpit/SJ room and the eggs chamber. You'll notice that both are flat against the surface of the planetoid, which would lead you too assume landing with correct orientation. Moreover, the eggs are in pristine condition - none have tilted or toppled over or look as if they've shifted due to... oh I dunno, a ship crashing down!? So what [i]is[/i] the normal way a Derelict would normally land? - because it could be that one of the two 'crashes' is actually a textbook landing.

Other discussions started by Starbeast

Replies to We know how it crashes, but how does a Derelict land?!

User Avatar
Apollo
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
@ Starbeast ... Well i didnt think it looked like it was moving the landing pad but maybe my eyes decieve me. However it may the perfect place for a landing pad. Inside the temple they are not just tunnels but look more like large caverns possibly, then basically refurbished by the jockeys, just as we have done throughout history. If they are natural caverns and tunnels which by the way in the trailer and some pics it does clearly look like they go down some strangely possibly naturally shaped tunnels. If this is the case it would make perfect sense that it is next to a waterfall as the water/ river whatever would in time have carved a cave system. Perhaps this temple, is an underground base/bunker/alien lab or anything rebel hidehout possibly. Dont just dismiss this theory yet. What else could that disk possibly be, it baffles me a lot but this is all i could come up with.
User Avatar
Starbeast
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
Yep point taken; we know very little about the waterfall scene, and I certainly haven't seen any discussions about whether the waterfall is an extension of the chambers we already know about. For it to be in the trailer, it must be of some significance, imo.
User Avatar
Game Over Man!
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
@Engr101 ~ I was just poking a little fun had that actually been what happened to the SJ and the ship crashing. :) I do agree what you are saying could be a possibility but I think it would be more of a deliberate action if the derelict came to rest above a xeno temple and an egg chamber at that. I personally think it would be to random to crash and end up in that exact spot. Just my opinion.
User Avatar
Herk Mondo
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
@bigbirdjimmy (and danrald too) Sorry guys but the last part of my earlier post wasn't actually aimed toward you to at all, but a third party and was for all to read though :-) ...apologies if that part of my post came across as being other wise :-). Oh and bigbird, I couldn't have said that better myself! Oh and danrald - totally! :-) I always thought that the egg chamber we see in Alien was a little too long-looking (especially in one particular shot - as looks to have an 's-bend' shape to at as someone else noticed) to be actually still within the derelict. But again, who knows for sure about this? And who knows if we'll even find out about that little puzzle. However its wall surface architecture/contruction was the same as what we saw in areas that were definately within the derelict. This could mean one of two things, a) the egg chamber is also of SJ origin just like the derelict, or b) the xenos have been at work setting-up home to encompas the derelict too (which is my personal preferance).

Join the discussion!



Join the Alien Movie, TV Series & Game online fan community!

Join the Alien Fan Community!

Create your own profile, contribute & engage with other Alien fans!

Recently Active Forums
New Forum Topics
Recently Updated Pages
Latest Alien Movie, TV Series & Game Media
Join the discussion!
Please sign in to access your profile features!
(Signing in also removes ads!)



Forgot Password?
Scified Website LogoYour sci-fi community, old-school & modern
Hosted Fansites
AlienFansite
PredatorFansite
AvPFansite
GodzillaFansite
Main Menu
Community
Help & Info
+

Sign In to contribute!