May 15, 2012This discussion is fascinating! And the various folks of various backgrounds, focuses and passions in here chatting about it make it all the more so.
I had not noticed the directory name as Eridu. More than making me think that everything in the story precisely mirrors Gilgamesh or similar, it leads me to believe that the folks on the show (making the movie) referred to the Engineers' "complex" as "Eridu" because that was a handy name for it and because a lot of of the motifs are inspired by Sumer.
@Davis, the word "valley" is used in the landing sequence and that would have been cut by a substantial river, which by the time of the "king has his reign" segment was probably what we see as Dettifoss in the trailer. Of course, I'm guessing on all of this. Thank you for your "creative contribution" to the discussion. That valley setting reminds me a lot of Teotihuacán. The valley walls are not as well defined (not as close) there in Mexico, but it's still evocative of the setting in the film.
[img]http://www.dartmouth.edu/~izapa/teotihuacan1p.gif[/img]
@Galzu, You really seem to love humanity's history and ALL of our mythologies. I imagine that if you and I compared libraries, there would be a lot of duplicate authors and titles. I think you make a really important point, that many of the most noteworthy events recorded in the Bible (Noah's flood, etc.) are actually much older stories that were woven into what I call the "authority of Moses". And, I think this points to the bigger picture of how I imagine this movie being made.
The idea of the Annunaki/Oannes/Watchers/Nephilim/Angels are all mixed up and interwoven into various (very different) traditions, some of which exist still only in "lost history" and others that are very real in modern society.
[url=http://www.ufo-contact.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/07/Ancient-Annunaki-Sumerian-Gods-Sacred-Pine-Cone-Fertilization-Pineal-Gland-Cave-of-Brahma.jpeg][img]http://www.ufo-contact.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/07/Ancient-Annunaki-Sumerian-Gods-Sacred-Pine-Cone-Fertilization-Pineal-Gland-Cave-of-Brahma.jpeg[/img][/url]
It seems to me that Thor's having appeared in the [i]Avengers[/i] is very much a parallel. He is a god and not of this earth. The Hulk has his "powers" conferred by science/genetics as does Cptn. America. Iron Man's is all mechanical. Black Widow and Hawk are "normal" humans with extraordinary training.
In fact, we can map (albeit artificially) Thor (or better Loki) to the Engineer, Iron Man to David, Black Widow to Shaw, Vickers to who knows what, and dump them all into a bowl, stir and get a story out of that which still resonates with our "sense of human experience". That's one reason why Avengers is such a box-office success. It fundamentally does not violate our sense of "something that is familiar and plausible" in the context of an existential threat. It doesn't matter how "out there" it is as long as it comes from our phychosocial "roots".
Now, all that said, it does seem that Ridley and the production were very focused on Sumer. I think that makes perfect sense because:
(a) Sumer is the earliest literate culture on earth and the cradle of our human [u]civilization[/u].
(b) Their language is an isolate. It cannot be mapped to have a genetic (linguistic) relationship to any other human language. That makes it seem like it might have been taught to humans by "others" (though that's certainly not likely the case).
(c) They wrote and left records that are mysterious to all but a handful of Sumerologists, because only they can read them. The vast majority of those texts are not very interesting (so many sheep, so many cows, etc.), but they LOOK exotic and mysterious. The writing in the film is roughly a 50/50 atmospheric mix of Sumerian cuneiform and Egyptian hieroglyphics. I will be thrilled if they have done some kind of legitimate linguistic work to come up with a spoken language for the Engineer, but I'm not excessively hopeful. There definitely was at least a NOD to this however. Dr. Anil Biltoo, a pedigreed linguist from SOAS (University of London) is on the project as a character (teacher), and this shot shows actual cuneiform (from Earth) in the data cube:
[url=http://www.prometheus-movie.com/uploads/prometheusmovie_11512_1.jpg][img]http://www.prometheus-movie.com/uploads/prometheusmovie_11512_1.jpg[/img][/url]
(d) The Sumerians and the Akkadians after them lasted for a very long time; as did the Egyptians mentioned above.
I think the Sumerians are a better choice for a "model human culture" in this film because, while very important, they are not as well known as the Egyptians to the modern world's populations. They are a bit more mysterious.
I can't WAIT for the film, but also for the ART book, because I won't be surprised if a lot of this didn't come out of the art department's research into how to best connect our "ancient aliens" legends to the world of the xeno zeitgeist. I'm sure that Ridley had a heavy hand in it, because he's so artistic in "that way" too.