love for Carrol, Giler and Hill

I know virtually the entire community despises these folks. But it has to be said: Without them we have: 1. No Ash 2. Ripley as a man (I realize that studio heads also were part of this, but stop giving credit to Scott; he had nothing, nothing, no thing, to do with this decision) 3. Big improvement in dialogue. Now, these two first changes to O'Bannon's already great original are absolutely iconic and loved by most. So who is willing to show them some love? Even if you hate every other choice they made after the original.