Alien: Earth and Alien: Romulus sequel news

Have I upset the staff here?

Mithra

MemberOvomorphJune 04, 20121986 Views39 Replies
I hope not, but my last two spoiler free posts, which expressed my polite thoughts after the 1st, and then the 2nd viewing, which both attracted interesting responses, seem to have vanished from the lists of posts? Is someone taking them down? Or am I missing something. The last thread is below........ After seeing the film on opening night, I was gutted : ( Now...for all you haters out there...that's just my opinion and we're all entitled to one. So back off all those who don't understand what an opinion is, or a discussion board where they can be aired. First time out, I thought the story was confused. The soundtrack, whilst good on album, was mismatched frequently against the scenes. The majority of characters were flat (although loved the interplay between Vickers and the ships captain) There was no fear, dread or terror and the promised sh*t was certainly not scared out of me by any stretch of the imagination. On the positive side, the visuals were stunning and David8 was the best android ever. But the ending was (IMHO) a huge piece of cheese. So much potential for being scary and emotion provoking missed. Having taken my son to see it last night with vastly reduced expectations, I feel slightly better. The film stands up on its own...but is certainly not the adult calibre film some of us hoped for. As regards a fitting prequel to the Alien film (and no one committed that it was).... not there yet..but scope for a sequel will see where that goes, and to be clear..I'm no longer bothered if it turns into a completely separate franchise on a complete tangent. My mind has let go of the upset and now has hope that the new story will develop along interesting lines. I asked my son (who is 20 years younger and not a huge fanboy like me) what he felt about it and he simply said, it was a 6/10 and an enjoyable film. I'm glad he enjoyed it and for all those of you who did. That's important. Life is too short and difficult not to enjoy a good night out at the cinema. For me, I'm still upset...but I DID enjoy some of the cinematic scenes and a glorious looking film. I hope those who got upset about it like me can watch it again after your expectations have been dashed. Let go of them now....the chance is gone. Watch it as a stand alone and it's an ok romp with beautiful visuals and some nice lines, with potential for an interesting sequel. Endings still cheese though : ) Spread the Love. Replies (13) shardy Member Send PM REPORT› Posted Jun-03-2012 4:16 PM i am glad that a bit of decompression from your initial viewing helped you to appreciate the film for what it is. i myself have not seen the film. i will this coming friday. i plan on seeing it again after that in IMAX i figured that some folks who weren't at all pleased or sated with this film, might look at it thru a different lens after seeing it a 2nd time. not to suggest you now love the film, but it seems that you don't disregard it as much as you did a short while ago thanx for this post mr pest Member Send PM REPORT› Posted Jun-03-2012 4:16 PM Thats exactly how I felt after 1st and 2nd viewings spot on pal alteredstate. Member Send PM REPORT› Posted Jun-03-2012 4:21 PM i'm booked in to see it again this time in 2d so after some initial upset like you i feel i can just relax on second view and hopefully take more away from it this time round i have seen an interview with ridley who said the 2d print is beautiful. Mithra Member Send PM REPORT› Posted Jun-03-2012 4:24 PM | Edit @Shardy and mr pest Thanks guys.... After huge expectations I felt gutted after seeing it and it really is good to have salvaged something. It's not a bad film...that's for sure. You can poke holes in lots of scripts you like. It's well worth a second viewing once you've taken your fanboy hat off. Was kinda cool taking my son to see it after my dad took me to see Alien. Phew....Thanks again guys. Mithra Member Send PM REPORT› Posted Jun-03-2012 4:27 PM | Edit @alteredstate. Hope you enjoy it pal. I sincerely feel your pain after the first viewing. It's nice as you say, to relax and just let it be a film and not something you pinned huge expectations on : ) Hope it helps put things right (well, better anyway : ) ) M dontwastyourtime Member Send PM REPORT› Posted Jun-03-2012 4:35 PM @Mithra: quite right about the music. It didn't match the action onscreen. But again, Prom is a B-movie, nothing more. It won't reach cult status like Alien or Blade Runner. Mithra Member Send PM REPORT› Posted Jun-03-2012 4:38 PM | Edit @dontwastyourtime I agree 100%. Chance missed. But....still chances for a sequel to learn from the mistakes. I may be grasping at straws...but hey...I never thought they'd make this film in the first place...so you never know. Cheers M LV 223 WRECK Member Send PM REPORT› Posted Jun-03-2012 5:45 PM hi everybody I was twice in first day and third other day...I am not a Alien RS fan let's say just a film archiver for a long time (tickets are very chip in my country 2,4 euro lol) I tried like you but no way.... some said 6/10....what a shame for a movie served like this...... ?? class movie served like A class movie.. it is about everything movie puh... you got the Shaw's axe hitted on your brains and looking for a chance to stay in life ha ha ha lol... let's be honest force DL use some cells seeded by SJs !! and resist to insulting by kiddish stupidly scripted movie making especially by RS so sequel may be 2 times awful than prequel. lol ...so resist for remaking of Prometheus it is a pleasure to be in this forum with you...kindly Mithra Member Send PM REPORT› Posted Jun-03-2012 7:05 PM | Edit @LV223 Wreck I understand how you feel. I hope that any sequel employs different writers. I hope it's more gritty and suspenseful. The grand ideas of this film need to be played out better in any sequel. Thank you for sharing your thoughts M sukkal Member Send PM REPORT› Posted Jun-03-2012 8:31 PM Mithra, I'm so glad that you feel better now. Your original disappoint was palpable. I'm not really a “fan boy about any movie overall, though many would likely call me that anyway. BUT, I do get passionate about certain aspects of films, and “wasted opportunity on any intentional endeavour is always disappointing to me, even to the point that I get angry from time to time. It makes me very happy that you're open to this film being something *different* from your original expectation(s). And, from a childless person’s perspective, the fact that you could go with your son as a shared experience is more valuable than any film itself as entertainment could ever be. Hudson Member Send PM REPORT› Posted Jun-03-2012 11:30 PM I actually went home after seeing Prometheus in a bad mood. I had been looking forward to seeing it for a long time. It was a real disappointment. Ridley Scott blew it. Mithra Member Send PM REPORT› Posted Jun-04-2012 5:55 AM | Edit @sukkal Thank you for taking the time to write that. I feel a bit better now that I've seen it again, had some general acceptance and that the rush of expectation has past. It would be foolish to let anger and upset get the better of me...it is only a film I know. : ) M Mithra Member Send PM REPORT› Posted Jun-04-2012 5:57 AM | Edit @Hudson I understand entirely. I went home gutted...very angry...Couldn't even talk to my friends much about it when we left the cinema as they weren't fanboys...So upset about the missed chances. M
User Avatar
Melkor
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
Staff seem to be taking a dim approach to 'negative' comments. Hopefully they will stop DELETING POSTS or they will drive away members.
User Avatar
Gavin
Group: Member
Rank: Trilobite
View Profile
I have took no such approach to "negative" comments, unless they are against the forum rules

User Avatar
Svanya
Group: Admin
Rank: Praetorian
View Profile
Staff are just regular users that got asked to help out. The most we do is moderate any personal attacks between members and repeat threads (Things that are against forum rules). If you have any issue with staff or posting, please PM BugHunter about it. As far as the movie goes, I haven't even seen it yet and i don't have an opinion. If you read my older comments you would know I respect others opinions, good or bad. We do not censor anyone's views.. I would also like to add that I am trying to remain as positive as I can, despite having had the the plot/story spoiled for me because of my moderating duties. I think people forget about that too, when they assume staff have some kind of agenda, that we have sacrificed so much to keep this forum a decent and welcoming place for people to be on. :(

Wat

User Avatar
Svanya
Group: Admin
Rank: Praetorian
View Profile
@melkor; No, I am sorry I cannot, because there are 10 moderators here and we don't know everything that everyone does. If you have questions, you should always mail BugHunter. I know you don't mean any harm, it's ok. We (the Staff) have been accused of so much wrong doing this week and it's hard to understand because we work so hard to make this site welcoming for everyone.

Wat

User Avatar
Melkor
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
Hi there Snorks and Svanya, no offense meant of course, but can anyone explain what happened to Mithra's posts?
User Avatar
Gavin
Group: Member
Rank: Trilobite
View Profile
What Svanya said, we each do what we can within the boundaries set by us by BH. If any member of the staff is suspected of overstepping those boundaries you should contact BH.

User Avatar
Vril
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
Snorkelbottom "contact BH" but what if it is BH (BugHunter)?...You know he went to sleep normal,but under his bed was a giant pod.......
User Avatar
Mithra
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
Since my posts have been , spoiler free, adult and fair and expressed a balanced view and the sincere wish that despite my feelings on the film, that everyone paying money to go and see it enjoys it on some level,.....It's rather disappointing that someone has removed the mails, especially with the feedback other forum users were giving it. Whoever chose to do it, really should examine their personal motives and the impact they have on an open discussion forum for adults. I have contributed discussion to this forum in the past and had some huge responses to my threads (76 responses in some cases). I'm sorry if one individual feels the need to censor opinions that don't align with their own. Thanks to all the other staff who have built such an excellent site which I have enjoyed immensely up to now. M
User Avatar
craigamore
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
Vril......Over the last few months, as I have come to know BH as personally as I can in this medium, through PM's and emails, I can say witha great deal of certainty that BugHunter would be the last of us to censor based on opinion........I can only say that I personally have not deteled any negative reviews, nor will I, unless they break our [url=http://www.prometheus-movie.com/community/forums/topic/2594]Forum Rules or Standards of Participation and Conduct - Please Read[/url].........IF ANYONE WITNESSES STAFF DOING ANYTHING OF THE KIND, INFORM BUGHUNTER AS WELL AS OTHER STAFF.... I have even defended their right to be negative in a few posts....I would like people to be more intelligent and rational about WHY they didn't like it, rather "it sucks" or "F@#% Ridley Scott" or "The B&*($% Lindelof" like some have....that's all I ask.....elaborate and be civil......Play nice....
User Avatar
Mithra
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
@craigamore I would hope you have read my posts and can see that not only am I polite and balanced, but that I also try and fend off those who hate contrary opinions and do not believe in free speech and discussion. It is very disappointing to see someone censoring views that don't align with their own, especially when they are written in a way as to be helpful and join in the spirit of this great forum. There are enough problems out there with people censoring the internet. I play extremely nice, and my posts have been genuine. The reason behind my last post was even to say that despite being very disappointed with the movie...there were a number of positives I hoped those others who were disappointed could take away....Can't get much more balanced than that from someone who was very upset by the movie. This forum has been great and the staff have done an excellent job, but this is a problem. A genuine 100% problem impacting free speech of the like minded people who enjoy coming here I hope you can resolve it with whoever is responsible. M
User Avatar
Vril
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
craigamore "Play nice." Do you really believe a giant pod is under BH's bed as he sleeps?
User Avatar
Svanya
Group: Admin
Rank: Praetorian
View Profile
@Mithra; I agree and feel very much that everyone on this forum has a right to their opinion and to be heard with respect. This place is meant for the exchange of ideas not insults and I apologize for your having had a bad experience here. Please don't let one bad apple, as it were, spoil the bunch. Regards, Svanya

Wat

User Avatar
Mithra
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
@Svanya Thank you for taking the time to say that. I hope you can nail the bad apple. I don't want him/her to spoil the bunch either..but when they have the ability to modify the forum to their own thoughts....you may find it tough to solve. Not sure how much they have changed to suppress views they personally don't like already. I hope the rest of you mods can track him/her into the air shafts or get it in an airlock and get back to the business of running such a great fun forum. You seriously have done an excellent job. M
User Avatar
Vril
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
Mithra Well said.
User Avatar
Mithra
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
@Vril Thanks Vril...now I'm seriously sleepy....and there's this damn pod under my bed?
User Avatar
Vril
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
Mithra Probably placed there by the ghost of Don Siegel.Or by Philip Kaufman and Donald Sutherland.Possibly all three !!! Sweet dreams....if any !!! Just don't wake up devoid of all human emotion.Hang in there man.
User Avatar
Mithra
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
@ Vril Thanks man...I can see Donald now...waiting for me over by the square...looks like he's ok...I'll go talk to him...he won't sell me out..... .......Doh!!!
User Avatar
Mithra
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
Is there a chance it's a bug (in the non-alien sense)? Both the removed threads show under my personal profile with"(SPOILER FREE)" appended to the title. Before this, they were still visible on the main forum. Could something have happened inadvertently? It's just a thought. I don't want to jump to the wrong conclusion over something that could be a glitch...Be good to nail it though. M
User Avatar
Gavin
Group: Member
Rank: Trilobite
View Profile
No worries Mithra... I think it was moved into the "Prometheus Reviews (Disliked)" section because it was probably considered a review, and the chance that spoilers may be posted by any whom replied in your thread - anything posted in either review section and the spoiler board does not show up in the main community area, so as to protect members from possible spoilers. That said it is a little perplexing that, with your thread being in the "Prometheus Reviews (Disliked)" section, that such a stipulation was placed on your thread which has resulted in the deletion of any posts containing spoilers. As mentioned before, your best bet is to rename your thread stating "possible spoilers" and request BH to have the text I mentioned in my previous post removed.

User Avatar
Gavin
Group: Member
Rank: Trilobite
View Profile
@ Mithra - have you checked the spoiler section, it may have inadvertantly been placed there.

Join the discussion!



New Forum Topics
Recently Active Forums
Alien: Earth
Alien: EarthDiscuss the Alien FX TV series here!
Alien Fan Art
Alien Fan ArtArtwork from Alien fans! Share yours here!
Alien: Covenant
Alien: CovenantDiscuss the Prometheus Sequel, Alien: Covenant
Alien
AlienDiscuss all things Alien here
Highest Forum Ranks Unlocked
Thoughts_Dreams
Thoughts_Dreams » Neomorph
89% To Next Rank
Neomorph
Neomorph » Chestburster
97% To Next Rank
VivisectedEngineer
VivisectedEngineer » Chestburster
73% To Next Rank
Jonesy
Jonesy » Chestburster
54% To Next Rank
auximenes
auximenes » Facehugger
30% To Next Rank
Latest Media
Join the discussion!
Please sign in to access your profile features!
(Signing in also removes ads!)



Forgot Password?
Scified Website LogoYour sci-fi community, old-school & modern
Hosted Fansites
AlienFansite
GodzillaFansite
PredatorFansite
Main Menu
Community
Help & Info
+

Sign In to contribute!