iapetusJune 12, 2012as much as I would want to know more, I have to agree with them that giving a lot away is the real disappointment in prequels/films, generally.
If you come to think of it, what more did you know at the end of Alien compared to what you knew at the beginning? Same thing goes for Star-Wars, after only Episode IV. And even after the 3 "classics", you still only had hints at what had once been. same thing again for Lord of the Ring, a lot is in between lines and not told, and you don't really know much of anything. Same thing, and even "worse" for more spiritual/philosophical classics (sci-fi or not) like 2001 for example. Clearly some people could consider 2001 like being led up, but I think no one would dare say it is not a masterpiece here.
As cliché as it may sound I think that mystery and unknown is what hooks you to a film/saga. When you do it, or more often do a prequel, with a plan to explain things, because that's what people want, you please them once on the spot, but kill the magic and spoil the rest of the story. See the SWars prequels, if it's not clear enough.
All in all, I think they did just good and balanced it "old school way", with just as many (if not more) new questions for every answer they gave.
Finally, I think it's us evolving in a bad, spoiled-child way as an audience. We're getting so used to being spoon-fed what we think we paid for that we find it annoying that things show some resistance and personality. Another thing is more specific to people on this site, I think. We all over-anticipated the movie, but also had pretty well developed and exact ideas of what we were to find in it. Hence, not only have we brought our hopes too high for the film but also for the number of new answers and confirmations it would bring. It is not so much that it brings too few, it is more that we here knew almost all of it before seeing the film. My sister & her boyfriend or my parents did not feel that way in the least. To them, it was filled as an egg with new things they had not foreseen. Keep in mind we're not treating that film fairly here, folks ;)