Does Aliens look less appealing as time goes on??

Otto
MemberOvomorphMay 09, 20122521 Views59 RepliesIt seems that "Aliens" is the LEAST "artistic" of all 4 movies in retrospect. In watching and paying attention to A.3 and A.4, it seems that A.2 is the "worst" as far as "real good art" goes, and we were "wrong, sooo wrong" with A.2....
A.1 is the "PERFECT" entity...a.3 and a.4 are far behind. But A.2 "Aliens" is actually the worst, artistically speaking...
May 09, 2012
Well you are right about How that should be enough to piss any fan off and it Is (not me though lol) but it's still not enough to call the ENTIRE story a rio off. Seams a little extream don't you think? Btw anyone else notice I am like the only one who really stands up for aliens on here? I mean there are plenty of people who say they like it, but almost never debate why it's good or defend it..... Cmon guys way to leave me solo lol :D
May 09, 2012
Oh that's fine :) as long as I know you are nit actually angry.... And I have never heard of that movie, us it one of his documentaries?
May 09, 2012
I love Aliens, it's got Bill Paxton in it, hello?! Lol. The action, it is an action film by the way, is awesome! Is the art direction in it good? Based on personal opinion...
[url=http://www.madmax4-movie.com/]Visit the Mad Max: Fury Road Forums today![/url]
May 09, 2012
[b]"In the Court Of The Krimson King.....aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhh"!!![/b]
May 09, 2012
I'll have to review them separately...
Alien -
Brilliant in every way.
Aliens -
Not particularly my kind of film, but good for what it is. It's just a very different kind of film compared to the first. I saw Avengers on Monday. Not really my kind of film either, but I understand why it's a commercial success. PS: I still love you Joss Whedon. My one complaint about Aliens is how much they changed the aliens. They did it for cost reasons (primarily). Cameron makes films that are VERY SUCCESSFUL with large audiences. He's very good at that. That's why FOX wanted him to do Nº 2.
Alien3 -
The cinematography is amazing. The IDEA is kind of interesting. I was disappointed in the special edition, though I guess it was a bit more logical. I love me a puppet or an animatronic, but the compositing was problematic. The script was not even finished when they wrapped. THAT was the biggest flaw. It showed. Fincher probably could have saved it at this point in his career, but SADLY, this is my least favorite.
Resurrection -
I actually liked it. I understand why some don't but. It has that [i]je ne sais quoi[/i] feel to it that just suits me. Ripley's character in it was interesting. Call was kind of interesting. I was genuinely surprised when the Newborn rejected the Queen. The fact that one xeno was sacrificed by two others so that they could escape was interesting to me. The xeno's ability to learn to use human technology was interesting. The researchers were HOR.RI.FIC! I just HATED the ending in Paris in the special edition. Apparently so did Jeunet.
Prometheus looks like all of these rolled into one and done on a 21st century scale. It won't be like Alien in "scope," but it will be amazing.
May 09, 2012
Ther plot of Fern Gully:
The fairy people of FernGully have never seen humans before, but when Christa sees one, Zak, she accidentally shrinks him down to her size. But there is trouble in FernGully, for Zak is part of a logging team who is there to cut down the forest. Zak goes on a wild adventure with Crysta. Eventually, Zak tells the truth about who he his and how the humans are destroying FernGully. The fairies join forces and fuse their powers together to fight the oncoming menace.
May 09, 2012
We can disagree about whether 'Alien' is brilliant...I call it a masterpiece of sci-horror, but that's me.....and no I'm not angry......now worries man...there's not no bad blood from my side...I just love to debate this stuff.
May 09, 2012
No, it's an animated kids movie from the early 90's that is basically 'AVATAR' from start to finish with numerous minute diffrerences but the same overall plot structure....
May 09, 2012
Oh, dude there are like a million things with that plot structure I already knew that lol I thought that he ripped off one of his own movies.
May 09, 2012
I'll probably be shot down for this but in my opionion (and it is just my opinion) the only thing about Aliens that seemed to scream 80s to me was some of the instrumental music and Paul Reiser and Sigorney's hairdos. Everything else was fantastic IMO.
But if we go to that level of criticism then we can also criticise the 70s visual effects of the model ships in the original Alien movie, the ancient computer screen readouts or the 70s horror orchestral score as the alien is about to strike. Those scream 70s to me IMO but apart from those scenes everything else in Alien looks and feels fantastic.
The more I watch Aliens the more amazed at how good it is and the more I watch Alien 3, the more amazed at how dull it is. Its artistic look give me the sort of feel you get from watching those cheaply made science fiction movies of the late 80s early 90s where they had minimal budget for special effects and instead focused on boring scenes and dialogue. For me, Alien 3is the worst of the series both in look and feel.
IMO it was Alien 3 that killed the series not Aliens. Hell, Alien 3 literaly killed everyone that James Cameron made us care about in Aliens including Ripley who was fleshed out more as a character.
I do accept the original point that Aliens is less artistic in its look compared to Alien, but it added so much more in substance and visuals than any of the movies that followed. Whenever a computer game is made in the Alien universe, its almost always set in the James Cameron version with marines, pulse rifles, auto turrets, dropships, apcs, etc;
Ane the less I say about Alien Resurrection the better except that I think it was better than Alien 3.
May 09, 2012
At work we call Avatar "Dances With Smurfs"
Safe? Of course he isn't safe, but he's good!
May 09, 2012
@otto: i agree with your assessment of " Aliens " and so on...
i think ALIEN(1979) was almost perfect in its depictions
and suggestions of what could truly be and look alien
as some of us have already well deduced,
Cameron had to dumb-down the alien, and turn it into a bug,
he nixed the domed head, and made the creatures teeth crystalline
instead of that hardcore looking stainless steel Scott gave is
the um " queen " creature was / is a total mess,
it looked really great in the trailers, but when i saw it in it's
entirety on screen, it looked very cheap and forced, not really
convincing to me anyway
the alien in Alien3 wasn't very impressive either,
i think those AWFUL mechanical looking FX didn't help it's case
Alien Resurrection was the same, bigger looking bugs,
all the more to trash and shoot up. BORING. the one redeeming
creature in A4 was the hybrid, i saw some pics of the unaltered
version of the alien hybrid, it looked really interesting, too bad
the studios had to wimp out and modify the sex organs in post
i am not happy with how the helmet to the bio-suit looks in
this new film, it is giving me way too much snuffleupagus,
and not enough intriguing looking Jockey that i knew from
ALIEN, at the same time, in the context of the film, it could
convince me, in the trailers so far...not-so-much
i do think the cobra-hugger looks great
May 09, 2012
In answer to the question, nope :-P
[url=http://www.robocopmovie.net/][img]http://i888.photobucket.com/albums/ac89/snorkelbottom/NewRoboBanner.jpg[/img][/url]
"Is it dead this time?" "I dunno, poke it with this stick and see."
May 09, 2012
Aliens sucked because of the over the top Marines and overly stupid lieutenant.
Resurrection sucked because of the goofy characters (caricatures).
Only Alien and Alien 3 were dead nuts serious, which made them kick ass.
May 09, 2012
Queen looks great idk what you mean :D and I hated the metal teeth, they looked spray painted and I can see the paint on the gums (probably my only complaint about the original suit) and I think only the queen had the crystal teeth, not the regular ones, and what makes the doam so important? I heard people say it's mysterious... I call bs, for the longest time I didn't even realize it was transparent until I started to get big into alien and I fund that the only mysterious thing was that it had no eyes, so taking the doam off made no deference to me.... And for the last time they were bugs to begin with! They were always supposed to be insect like.
May 09, 2012
I agree with you W2rh, accept for the alien 3 being the worst I still think 4 is the worst by far IMO. And refere back to my earlier comment about the marines arnis :)
May 09, 2012
I gotta jump in here. For sure, Alien is the best. However, whenever I see those old CRT's (vs. today's touch screens and digital displays) it's for sure dated. Look at Mother's font as she scrolls out the messages to Dallas. So how can we not say Alien is dated. Consider Prometheus, a pre Alien story - you've got to ignore the glass cockpits and other technologies that are much more modern then what we saw in Alien. I don't care that the Nostromo was a cargo/tow ship - how can it be so technologically far behind what we see in Prometheus?
I can't say that Alien 3 looked good - it was all in all (my opinion) a poor movie and the beginning of the end of the Alien franchise as we once knew it.
For sure, Aliens had a different feel and for what it was meant to portray (a tough USMC squad) - but it rocked!!