Forum Topic

BelieveItOrNot
MemberOvomorphJun-14-2012 6:15 PMThe one question that stuck with me was “Who created the Engineers?” What if the Engineers were not really our creators but instead just an earlier experiment created by an altogether different race that we haven’t seen yet? It stands to reason that we would have similar DNA to the Engineers and all other races created by these “Creators” as all their children races would come from similar experiments.
Perhaps the Engineers were made by the Creators to assist with experiments throughout the Universe and generally to serve, much like David and the Robots were created to serve humans. For a time, the Engineers were treated as children to the Creators and had their place. As part of their duties, the Engineers seeded planets with DNA and then visited them and guided races like us through our development, on behalf of the Creators. Then something happened and humans began to display special characteristics. They began to show more potential than any of the other experimental races including the Engineers.
The Creators decide to groom the Human Race to achieve its potential and to some day replace the Engineers – model 2.0. Not able to accept this, the Engineers feel betrayed and turn on the Creators (much like the Robots apparently turn on the humans later in the ‘Alien’ timeline) and there is some kind of a war or rebellion between the Engineers and the Creators. The rebellion goes poorly for the Engineers until, looking for a weapon to fight their makers, they learn of the Xenos – a race even older than the Creators themselves.
They manage to harvest old DNA and create a biological weapon from the Xenos. As we’ve seen from all the Alien films where someone has attempted to control them, the Xenos get out of control and become an even bigger threat to the Engineers than the Creators. The Engineers are all but wiped out by the creatures. The remaining few Engineers formulate a desperate action: destroy the human race who are supposed to supplant them. This is meant as strategy (without a replacement will the Creators reconsider their position on the Engineers) and also revenge (the only avenue left to strike back at the Creators).
It’s a gamble that fails when a final infestation breaks out preventing the ship that was meant to strike Earth from ever even taking off. Prometheus takes place 2000 years after this failed attempt to kill the human race. Why did the Engineers not make any further attempt during that time? There were none left to do so, or at least none of rebellion Engineers left. Somehow the one Engineer we meet in the film escaped the fate of the others and realizes resumes his mission. Remember, at one time the Engineers took care of the Human Race on behalf of the Creators. I think this is why the Engineer affectionately strokes David’s hair before attacking him. The Engineer was moved by how far the “children” they once cared for had come and perhaps a little sad at all having to kill them.
If Shaw succeeds in her plan, she may actually discover all this in Prometheus II. However, in the theme of “children killing their parents”, it’s worth noting that she and David are flying through space with a payload of Xeno bio-weapons in their cargo (assuming their ship is like the other). Will she succeed in her quest to meet the true makers of the human race? Will she inadvertently bring death to the world of remaining Engineers or maybe even to the Creators themselves? “A King has his reign and then he dies.” I guess we’ll find out…
8 Replies

BelieveItOrNot
MemberOvomorphJun-14-2012 8:09 PMSid -- I couldn't disagree with you more. This film is art in a way that is rare among science fiction movies. It asks questions and rather than spoon feeding us the answers from the film makers point of view, we are given several possibilities - several avenues - to finding answers. How many films in recent memory have sparked the kinds of water cooler chats this one has? Prometheus sparks discussions like those on these boards because the film asks important questions, and the answers we choose to them reveal a bit about ourselves. Do I see a few flaws in the film making? Yes. Here and there. Overall it's a fine film and an ambitious use of the genre that few outside of Scott would even attempt.
The fact that people who claim to dislike the film have made the effort to register on sites and join the discussion says something too wouldn't you say?

Sid
MemberOvomorphJun-14-2012 7:28 PMI think you are all reading too much into what is a poor movie.Yes you could be right but for the money this film cost and the money you guys paid to see it ,you should have the answers. Yes these big muscular lugs appear to be disposable foot soldiers.Maybe the one at the end crapped himself because we are top of the food chain after all,the ultimate weapon.But you spent your cash and nobody knows.Ever feel youve been cheated ?

BelieveItOrNot
MemberOvomorphJun-14-2012 8:25 PMSukkai - you're right about the religious angle to this theory. Creators = God(s). Engineer = Angels. Xenos = Demons. The notion of fallen angels and the like is a common thread running through even some of the more ancient religions with 'evil' being born as a result.

sukkal
MemberOvomorphJun-14-2012 6:29 PMThe sibling rivalry axis is interesting, but those rivalries generally exist because individuals are raised side by side.
The other model is G_D loving humans more than the angels and the angels being jealous. I think that's covered rather thoroughly in [url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dogma_(film)][i]Dogma[/i][/url].

Hadley's Hope
MemberOvomorphJun-14-2012 6:31 PMDid you consider at all the possibility that the Engineers are just genetically modified earthlings, scooped up on all those visits to Earth. A bit of gene inhibition to remove most of the skin pigments, nipples and body hair... add in some steroids, (or just keep breeding the big ones until you get a serious giant) , and badda - bing... a slave race to do the dying and killing.
Of course the thing with slaves is that they do eventually rebel. They need to be made an example of. A terrifying punishment. What would a bunch of DNA fiddlers do to a bunch of tall biosuit wearing giants...
Who knows? Turn them into something tall, slightly mechanical, and very unpleasant to be around perhaps? Wow, if I pulled that off, I'd put images up on the walls as constant reminders.
I think the engineer strokes Davids hair because deep down, somewhere he knows he shouldn't be bald. He's got perfect teeth, great abs, but NO shot at as a model for shampoo.. hence he's stuck working on LV 223.

kay
MemberOvomorphJun-14-2012 6:36 PMI think your right the aliens that sent the egineer to kick start
life on earth..could be be also responsible for creating our sun... ancient scripture..says earth was created before our sun,this we know is scientifically imposible. Yet just imagine if that was the way it happened i think our creators wil be non coporeal...
I can see shaw going on a long journey across galaxies and through wormholes until finally she'll get to the gates of paradise to where the creators live it will be strange and wonderful...and shaw will probably have to have her mind expanded...to fathom it.

Hadley's Hope
MemberOvomorphJun-14-2012 6:42 PMIf shaw brings a shipload of wigs, it will improve the Space Jockey morale and solve a lot of cultural tensions between the Space Jockeys and their overlords.
Seriously, even a hat or something. They can provide 3D holograms spanning 35 light years of space, but nothing to keep people making 'bald' jokes. No wonder they are so grumpy.
Add A Reply