Forum Topic

Jeystone
MemberOvomorph01/5/2012I mean come on...you have the derelict, LV 426...it is set before Alien..it describes the origins of the jockeys...and it's still not meant to be a prequel? Why? because there is no xenomorph? please, you would need a much bigger reason than that
This is a prequel and anyone that argues otherwise I think has a rather low IQ..the kind of people who argue about what genre a song is, when it is completely irrelevant.."That's not dubstep man it's dubstep-electro"...please
69 Replies

shardy
MemberOvomorph01/5/2012it's a fuckin' prequel. anyone who says otherwise has bought Fox's
transparent marketing campaign, hook-line-and sinker. just sayin'.....

danrald
MemberOvomorph01/5/2012It's kinda a prequel but in a way such as:
"Patriot Games" is to "Hunt for Red October" or
"Casino Royal" is to "Thunderball"

Manndroid
MemberOvomorph01/6/2012Already wasted a lot of digital ink explaining how prequel is defined, regardless of one's opinion, or preference for how the word is used, so I rest my case.
Zeus' last post here acts beautifully as a closing statement for my own contributions. Thank you, sir.

visualizer
MemberOvomorph01/6/2012[quote]Right. Though with the proviso that it involves a story arc introduced in the previous works, as added by the Webster variant.[/quote]
I actually think, that both the Dictionary.com and Webster definitions are open to interpretation. Furthermore, definitions might change over time, as/if the phenomenons they describe, change and evolve. But I understand the need to base your answers on something that feels valid and secure. Whether or not Prometheus is a prequel, nobody knows - that´s not the issue. I don´t necessarily agree or disagree with you on your conception of Prometheus being a prequel or not, but I kind of disagree with your interpretations of the dictionary descripitions and your faithful commitment to them.
To follow up on your latest contribution on this topic; if u wrote what u wanted to write, then It is not a waste of digital ink IMO. You can write something in here, and watch it get twisted, misunderstood or used as platform for cheap and self-satisfied punchlines, apparently that´s the name of the game in here. But thank you for a pleasant and impartial dialogue about this subject.

red hood
MemberOvomorph01/7/2012http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1446714/
cocooned man - just another DNA link to the Alien world.
jonesaholic
MemberOvomorph01/12/2012[quote]Prometheus is NOT a prequel, per se. It is a... the best phrase seems to be "spin off".[/quote]
you were saying, snorkelbottom?

Gavin
MemberTrilobite01/12/2012Your first post is that, especially when I've already posted on the news topic (which you should read properly). Was I the only one with this view, no.
Move on.
Add A Reply