Forum Topic

whiskuz
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 12:11 PMAt 11:39 of the super slo-mo trailer you can see a human-sized character attacking Shaw. This character is obviously human-sized, but it has a pattern on it's legs very similar to that of the blue guy in the chair chamber.
Is this David having been commandeered by the SJs/Engineers and "modified" by their technology?
Or is it the mutated crew member? Could there be a mechanized component to his mutation?
What do you guys think?
63 Replies

spacyfreak
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 12:33 PMI think there is no living engineer - some of the crew gets infected and "mutates to an old species" wich has gone long ago. They needed our dna component to come to live again...
Bonus Situation
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 1:25 PMIt's an alien. It is not a crewmember. It is not David or one of the other cast whose names you never heard before.
It is an alien. Not THE alien from the first film, but an alien we have yet to see fully.
Why would Scott cast Fassbender, with his eye-candy looks, only to convert him to some unrecognizable alien character halfway through the story. Not gonna happen. Scott paid plenty for Fassbender's pretty mug, and he is not going to cover it up.
It's not a crew member, either. If Scott made the final confrontation between Shaw and someone else, it's not going to be some no-name crew member. I have never heard of most of the cast actors until this year, and by making the final confrontation between Shaw and the "creature" essentially a confrontation between Rapace and some actor nobody has heard of until now, well, that's not very exciting, is it. It would make one of the supporting actors one of the main actors, wouldn't it. That is not how movies work. The big names - Theron, Fassbender, Rapace - they get the main characters, not some nobody. And the big names don't get their entire faces and bodies changed into some unrecognizable form. What is the studio paying the big bucks to the A-list acotrs for? To be SEEN.
Your theory is not even close.

lush
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 1:38 PM^ MF is a robot - there could be loads of him, so one getting mutated is nothing.
regarding your big paragraph, well that s exactly what happened in alien...

draekus
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 1:44 PM@bonus situation
Isn't that what RS did in Alien? Granted, times have changed, but dont underestimate Ridley on this one.

spacyfreak
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 1:57 PMwell rapace is also not "so big" in hollywood like for example angelina jolie (though i did not like ANY of jolies roles, to me simply a boring, bad actress..haha.. but she has heart for poor children, or maybe thats just a fashion nowadays, i dont care..).
Anyway - the "thing" attacking rapace is the "kojak-type" who walks at the spacejokey-chair-room.
Where did he come from? I believe he was a crew member and mutated.
Something else - what the hell is THIS? A face?
[img]http://www.pictureupload.de/originals/pictures/090412211712_engineer.png[/img]

whiskuz
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 2:09 PMFirst of all, I never stated a theory, just facts and questions.
Second, on the topic of why studios hire actors, I'm not sure if you've ever heard of this thing called "acting," but it's something actors do. Some actors are better than others at "acting," and once in a while an actor gets hired because of how good they are at it, not because of their looks. I know, I know, I didn't believe it either.
So tell me, why did a studio pay Charlize Theron to be fat and ugly in Monster? According to your theory, that would never happen.
Third, everyone in this forum but you knows there are multiple "creatures" in this film, as Ridley has said so explicitly. I never stated this was "the" creature.
Fourth, your claim that defacing/destroying a beautiful person is not a theme in film is pretty silly. Do you watch movies????. Examples: English Patient, [add in any number of the hundreds of films that have explored this theme].
Bonus Situation
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 2:23 PMScott is not going to cover up Fassbender halfway through the movie and make him completely unrecognizable.
Scott is not going to cover up Theron halfway through the movie.
No-name actors, yes, he is going to cover them up or get them killed off.
What a stupid movie it would be if some random crewmember turns into the alien being we have all wondered about for the past 30 years. Stupid stupid stupid. "Oh, it's just a guy that used to be a human. Great."
It is easier to believe that the Prometheus crew meets members of an alien civilization that it is to believe they simply meet themselves as "mutated" crew members? Obviously one or more crewmembers undergo a physical change, but you are telling me that they change into a 13 foot alien being? And then by virtue of changing into a 13 foot alien being they just know how to operate all the mechanical devices found on the planet? They simply just know how to make an alien ship rise from the surface of the planet? Sure, I can get a face transplant now and undergo a transformation, but that doesn't mean I now know karate or how to operate a nuclear reactor. That is just silly.
Scott says the human crew finds a civilization, a civilization that behaves uncivilized.

whiskuz
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 2:25 PMOMFG...what are you talking about??????? Where are you getting all this nonsense from?????
You must be new here. Please re-read my OP.

draekus
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 2:27 PM@Whiskuz
its just bait!!! stop being drawn in before its too late!!! LOL
Bonus Situation
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 2:30 PMIt's clear as day what I am saying.
David does not turn into some mutated creature that then goes and attacks his crewmates. That is a stupid plot. I just demonstrated how fullof holes that plot would be.
OK, let's say that is David, now completely unrecognizable. So Fassbender is only in half the film, and the second half he is replaced by a different actor wearing prosthetics.
So how does mutated David - or anyone else for that matter - how does he know how to fly the U shaped alien craft? Please do tell me.

whiskuz
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 2:31 PMIf that is your answer to the question I posed, then why is it human-sized? You didn't answer that part.
If it were as big as the blue guys are in the other shots, no mystery...but it isn't. Hence the question.
Bonus Situation
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 2:35 PMYou haven't seen the entire sequence, so you cannot judge the proportions based on a one second clip.
You haven't answered my question:
If the main antagonist or creature is simply a transformed crewmember, how do they know how to raise the 'cannon' and fly the alien ship? Won't that require a lot of explanation and boring exposition?

Spartacus
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 2:39 PM@SPACEYFREAK,
Gotta say it 'cause I love film. I do not think her roles have been that exciting to me EITHER , but Angelina Jolie has gotten this far because she isn't just pretty, she is a FABULOUS ACTRESS DUDE. INCREDIBLE EVEN...A VERY VERY VERY ACCOMPLISHED AND TALENTED ACTRESS. PERIOD.

whiskuz
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 2:47 PMYes you can. Her lower leg and knee is right next to it's and it is almost as tall even though it is at an angle and not straight up and down. If you don't believe that, look at the door. This is on the human-sized ship.
Where are you getting the "main antagonist" element from? I never suggested this thing is the main antagonist. You are assuming that the mutated crew member is the main antagonist. And that doesn't address the possibility of the android becoming "infected" by their technology in some way shape or form. Notice I'm not saying "becomes the antagonist."
I'm not hearing a theory that explains the size of the creature from you, which was the purpose of the post.

artyoh
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 2:50 PM@Bonus Situation
Frankly, your contention that Scott wouldn't cover up [i]any[/i] of these actors in prosthetics, make them unattractive etc., halfway through the movie is nonsensical. As was already pointed out to you, directors do that kind of thing all the time, and actors often accept roles which call for it, because they tire of playing similarly "glamorous" parts.
To answer your last question, there are numerous instinctual animal reactions/behaviors which are hard-wired into their DNA. For example, a baby bird doesn't need to observe a snake eating another bird, to know that it represents a significant threat. The SJs can apparently manipulate DNA on a very profound, sophisticated level, so we can presume that including "race memories" in a strand of DNA wouldn't be any more difficult than programming in C is for us.
Bonus Situation
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 3:03 PMI will put it this way:
I am very
very
very
very
very
very glad you had nothing to do with the story or scriptwriting for Prometheus.
Michael Fassbender, a very fast-rising A-list actor, would never agree to be cast in a part that requires him to do essentially voice acting the second half of the film, assuming the creature he supposedly becomes has a speaking part. And let's say the creature does have a speaking part - you gonna tell me it will be Fassbender's voice? So the nature of David is completely and utterly changed into something else yet it retains Fassbender's voice. Stupid.
Never will happen.
You will see that the humanoid standing over Shaw is the same creature seen in the star map chamber, or one of the same kind. It is an alien being.
What a stupid plot to have the android go rogue and start attacking people - again. They did that on ALIEN. It's been doen to death. Move on.

whiskuz
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 3:05 PMI think you are still missing the point. I didn't say I think that's what happens. Why is the creature human sized?
Bonus Situation
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 3:09 PMYou will have to wait and watch the movie to find out.
But I don't think the individual standing over Shaw is human-sized. It is much larger. You cannot get a proper perspective from a one second clip.

whiskuz
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 3:12 PMAnd BTW, I guarantee you Michael Fassenbender would do just about anything asked of him in order to be in this film.
Bonus Situation
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 3:13 PM"To answer your last question, there are numerous instinctual animal reactions/behaviors which are hard-wired into their DNA. For example, a baby bird doesn't need to observe a snake eating another bird, to know that it represents a significant threat. The SJs can apparently manipulate DNA on a very profound, sophisticated level, so we can presume that including "race memories" in a strand of DNA wouldn't be any more difficult than programming in C is for us."
You are telling me that just as the story is revving up to the climax, they are going to stop everything, turn to the audience, and try to explain why David, an android, or some former crewmember who has now grown seven feet in height, had gained several hundred pounds of muscle, instantly knows how to operate alien technology and even pilot a massive alien spacecraft out of its hangar and into the air? You really gonna ask the audience to swallow that?
The most simple explanation is that you are wrong. You are completely wrong.

whiskuz
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 3:17 PMWow, so they can engineer life...but they can't upload flight instructions into a computer. I think making sense of that for the audience would take a little longer...don't you think?

Spartacus
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 3:20 PMPlease if I may, go easy on each other 'cause it looks like you guys are getting somewhere together.
Bonus Situation
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 3:20 PM"And BTW, I guarantee you Michael Fassenbender would do just about anything asked of him in order to be in this film."
Don't think so.
He is in this film [i]to be seen[/i].
Yes, he will do anything if it involves displaying his natural good looks and acting talent. But they are not going to have in in for part of the film and them swap his character out for some completely different character.
What Theron did in MONSTER was for Oscar bait. You still knew it was Theron. It's not like they put her in a fat suit, put on a mask and put her on stilts, then made her stop reciting dialoge.
The rogue android cliche has been done to death. Why do you want more of it?
So glad you didn't write the story.

Spartacus
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 3:23 PMnot sure it was Oscar bait, think she genuinely believed in that role/character considering what happened in her own life at the hands of and then to her own Father.

artyoh
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 3:24 PMNone of the doors/hallways we've seen in the trailers are large enough to accomodate 13 ft. tall creatures, unless they moved around in a crouching posture....... 10 ft. is a pretty good approximation of the height of the doors/halls.
I provided a plausible explanation that could account for why someone who's DNA has been completely altered, might have an entire body of knowledge which they previously didn't have access to. There are literally tens of thousands of examples in the natural world, where creatures behave on instincts which have been programmed into their DNA through evolution. Sorry, but if Scott wanted to use that idea, it would actually dovetail perfectly with SJ tech.

BigDave
MemberDeaconApr-09-2012 3:26 PMWe just dont know whats going to happen.
I think Ridley is going to go a very risky route and do something thats out side the box, that could work and rock, or suck hard.
logically it would be that the Aliens in movie are Space Jockey, Organism that transforms its host into Mutant and then infected DNA that Mutates a Embrio in Shaw.
But what may happen maybe be more extream and so we cant rule out crew being changed into Space Jockey or the Xeno, we cant rule out David becoming the Space Jockey.
They dont make much sence that way to me, but i guess that what we will find out to really happen could be a suprise to what many of us think is going on.
R.I.P Sox 01/01/2006 - 11/10/2017

Spartacus
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 3:28 PM[url=http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-506285/My-brother-monster-Charlize-Therons-aunt-disputes-stars-account-shooting-pleads-wont-speak-dying-grandmother.html]CharlezeStory[/url]
Add A Reply