So Alien Prequel was going to start off on LV-426.... Ridley said he always felt LV-426 was Paradise.... Now the Badge and Symbolism confirms this?
Lets look at ways to discount this...
First... if LV-426 is Paradise and the Place the Covenant lands down on then it was a Lush World of Vegetation, Water back then and not a Baron Rock devoid of breathable atmosphere as in Alien. Can such a World that seems Hospitable become so Baron and Inhospitable within less than 20 years to Alien... YES!
Alien Engineers the World is described as Dark, Grey and can not support Human Life without any Space Suit.
But we can discount Alien Engineers as Canon, so maybe LV-426 could be a Paradise like the Location in New Zealand?
However... case point 1... Prometheus..
Holoway and the Star Map.... first of all does the Star Map Configuration show 6 Stars or 6 Planets, or a Planet and 5 Moons. This is important to determine how exactly these Match the Zeta 2 System.... and how come Holoway pointed to one particular body...
He did so in a way to indicate a Star, that has a Planet, that has ONE MOON that may sustain Life.... and they arrived there in the morning...
If this ONE MOON is not to mean One Moon but that only One Moon can potentially Support Life then do we assume this Moon is LV-223?
This would then mean by the time of Prometheus December 2093 only LV-223 was the only Place that could closely support life... if we assume and as it appears to be CANON that LV-223 and LV-426 are Moons around the same RINGED GAS GIANT then if only One Moon may be able to support Life that means Holloway was referring to either LV-223 or LV-426... but as he said we arrived there this morning in regards to the ONE MOON this would mean LV-426 is less Habitable than LV-223 and thus nothing like Paradise or what ever World Covenant is set on as far as Scenes shot in New Zealand...
We have to assume Prometheus is Canon, are they going to ignore everything from Prometheus?
So if the system that LV-223 is part of, does not have immediately near by i.e LV-426 a World that is a Paradise as far as a Place that could support life with its Environment based of the Shooting Locations in New Zealand....
Then how can LV-426 be Paradise... and how then does that Covenant Bade fit in.... it could fit in with showing LV-426 Paradise, LV-223 and then the Planet Calpamos
The Weyland Viral Timeline the Company discovered that system and LV-426 Acheron in 2039 "Weyland astronomers discover multiple moons and a ringed planet just outside the Zeta 2 Reticula System, which are possibly able to support life. Weyland expects to travel there within the century."
This shows the potential for Life.. it does not rule out LV-426 from being able to... but i would go with Holloway and how there was ONE MOON that potentially could and they arrived at that Moon (LV-223) but again maybe Holoway overlooked LV-426 but i fail to see how as they arrive near LV-223 he would miss that LV-426 is a far more habitable world.
Most references to LV-426 Acheron suggest it is a Dead Rock as of 2122. Acheron has a number of meanings that can apply to Prometheus Back Story but this is for another subject or later.
Strike 1 (or maybe not)
So how can a Baron LV-426 be Paradise... maybe there is a clue in what Micheal Beihn said about Alien Covenant and how it was set THOUSANDS of years before Aliens.
How? and could LV-426 had been like Paradise thousands of years ago... YES! maybe?
If so and if we assume Paradise, Covenant, the Badge and Cherubs who protect Paradise/Eden and Planet Formation point to LV-426 as Paradise... then how does this place be a Lush World?
Answer... either something happens that allows David to Travel Back in Time, or Engineer Ships can do this... If Engineer Ships can do this, then why have they never been back to undo things such as creation of Mankind, the Outbreak on LV-223 the failed destruction of Mankind... unless a Covenant was made to prevent this.. (come to that latter). But yes its possible... as far as Technology but then a Covenant to re-frame from trying to kill us off had occurred at some point.
So thats a theory that could work....
But we have to assume how the Hell does the Covenant arrive on a LV-426 Paradise when it is in a state of Paradise as far as Habitable Lush World?
Oh the one part of the synopsis and more so Ridleys comment about "they are going on that ship" With a new group of Travelers incoming"
So Covenant follows David and Shaw? Well with the Alien Covenant Crew confirmed as Weyland Yutani that rule out a few things..
How does the Covenant follow.. and surely they are not on board the Juggernaut but following? Here is the PROBLEM If LV-426 is Paradise, which is a short distance from LV-223 how long would a Engineer Ship get from one Moon to another? Not very long.. not even a day, not even a hour maybe? maybe even minutes.?
so for the Covenant to be following it then how can that be? David sets off Jan 1st or so 2094 when LV-426 is a rock.... it dont take David 10 years or less to get to LV-426? surely?
What about how it becomes a Paradise and not Baron? Time Travel or something... Why would David want to go back.. unless he knows the Engineers are dead.. but they was not thousands of years ago and so he knows how to jump back in Time...
But then for the Covenant to enter LV-426 Paradise it would have to maybe jump into the same Worm Hole/Time Shift that Davids Juggernaut enters..
How does such a Hole in Time and Space, occur and how long would it remain open? surely not be Alien and Aliens....? (UNLESS ITS IN A SPECIFIC PLACE). And oh dear the Sulaco enters it too, or maybe the blast on LV-426 at the end of Aliens re-opens it so one Sulaco passes through into a Parallel universe Alien 5... while the other carries on to Alien 3
Could this Link Alien Covenant and Alien 5... remember i said remember Terminator Genisys lol
But how did the Covenant knew Davids ship went through this opening that allowed Time Travel? a worm hole that you come out of the other end... in the same place but thousands of years prior... the IDEA WORKS! a COVENANT with the Engineers could explain why we dont see them bother to destroy us again.
But how does the Covenant know where Davids ship went?...
Or does David stay on LV-223 do some research, then LV-426 and then he figures out what happened... and then he makes the TIME SHIFT Jump... but just as Covenant is entering the System.... or maybe he sees the Covenant and he goes back in time to undo something but Covenant slips through the back Door...
Having David hanging around for 10 years on LV-223 and LV-426 and then somehow triggering a event that throws the ship back in time... just as Covenant is in bound WOULD AGAIN Fix this..!
So again this avoids Strike 2? and Strike 1?
Nope because here Comes Strike 3!
If we take the last theory which could work... either which way.. (Space Time Hole/Tear is open for years after David passed and Covenant passes through... or David has been hanging about for a while and only enters/creates it just as the Covenant is incoming).
Then why would the Crew of the Covenant be thinking they are arriving at Uncharted Paradise...
Why would they be in that system as David enters a Time Shift or they enter the remains of a Time Shift... when surely in the timeline of the Covenant entering that system LV-426 is not Paradise... Unless LV-223 is this Paradise.. but surely Weyland Yutani would know thats not quite the case?
Unless we got a first attempt of a Order 937 on our Hands? But then would they not intercept Shaws SOS... if they do would they not want to be asking Questions about Shaw in the movie... if they either detect the SOS, or if they are aware of the fate of Prometheus.
I would suggest the Synopsis points to them being non the wiser and that they find David as a surprise... as they thought they was the first to discover a uncharted Paradise... when LV-223 is Charted... maybe covered up and LV-426 is not a Paradise.
So while the Weyland Yutani Badge can give us clues to allude to Paradise as LV-426 i have came up with 3 Strikes against it and even a Final Nail in the Coffin.. or maybe not!
However i feel the Uncharted Paradise, and lets see this part "Bound for a remote planet on the far side of the galaxy"
I dont think LV-223/426 at 39 Lights years is the Far side of the Galaxy... and both are not a Planet..
I would assume 1) Engineers are from a Planet and not a moon, and 2) while they was not stupid enough to build those Weapons on their own Doorstep.... (LV-223) i still think LV-426 is still a bit to close for comfort as far as messing about with stuff... this would be like taking a Dangerous Experiment from out of the House and into the Garage
What do you guys think?