Comments (Page 5)

Glad somebody agrees @LoveSciFi

This show had so much potential. I hope season 2 will be the last. Unfortunately they wont cancel season 2. 

Chris, I tried to click quote and comment on this person and it didn't work so I am going to just put what they said in quotation marks: "And yeah, Wendy has been given way too much power and control over things. A character like this is never entertaining to watch. She as a character is interesting in few episodes but the script was not creative enough. Cheesy phrases and grunge/metal music at the end does not help also." I agree with everything this person typed.
​

Would like to see the writers kill off all the lost boys, with Wendy being the first to go because she's so evil. Then I would like to see all the way the aliens were captured and where they are from. Wouldn't anyone like to see a planet with all octopus eye monsters?

I'd like for you to give me your reason on why you find Wendy to be evil

No, the music doesn't belong in this series.

I absolutely loved the Alien Earth series! The new types of alien species introduced to us was awesome, especially the Eye! I mean, come on! I'm so looking forward to seeing the next season. Great job!

I think maybe (apart from the subjective viewpoint) the division between liking or disliking in general is due to generational differences. People, particularly sci-fi/horror fans who grew up watching the original films might prefer those for what they are and also in hindsight for nostalgic reasons, but I doubt people were as divided with the difference between Alien and Aliens as they are with Alien and Alien Earth for example. Ridley Scott and James Cameron are simply among the best directors (especially when they were young imo) and set the standard for Alien so high it's impossible to top, especially from the perspective of old schoolers.I also think, and this is admittedly a rather bold statement, that there's truth to the matter that directors, writers and people overall back in the day were simply- with the lack of a better word, "smarter" in general as they really had to think themselves without the aid of countless computer applications doing the work for them. This applies to other areas as well such as piloting an aircraft without numerous assisting instruments.With exceptions of course, applies to both then and now.This is correct. Writing is inherently dumber or maybe audiences are smarter are more likely it's both. Star Wars is a good example in the streaming age. Andor is written to damn near perfection. The Mandalorian (the first two seasons anyway) are dumb but fun. The Ashoka and Obi Wan Kenobi series are just dumb.

Good examples, I agree.

I think maybe (apart from the subjective viewpoint) the division between liking or disliking in general is due to generational differences. People, particularly sci-fi/horror fans who grew up watching the original films might prefer those for what they are and also in hindsight for nostalgic reasons, but I doubt people were as divided with the difference between Alien and Aliens as they are with Alien and Alien Earth for example. Ridley Scott and James Cameron are simply among the best directors (especially when they were young imo) and set the standard for Alien so high it's impossible to top, especially from the perspective of old schoolers.I also think, and this is admittedly a rather bold statement, that there's truth to the matter that directors, writers and people overall back in the day were simply- with the lack of a better word, "smarter" in general as they really had to think themselves without the aid of countless computer applications doing the work for them. This applies to other areas as well such as piloting an aircraft without numerous assisting instruments.With exceptions of course, applies to both then and now.

This is correct. Writing is inherently dumber or maybe audiences are smarter are more likely it's both. Star Wars is a good example in the streaming age. Andor is written to damn near perfection. The Mandalorian (the first two seasons anyway) are dumb but fun. The Ashoka and Obi Wan Kenobi series are just dumb. 

For the reasons you stated i reject Scott's claims that they were created. It's definitely the case with his head canon but there's no chance in hell David created them. Too much evidence against it. David imitated and was successful thus the praetomorph being far from the perfect Organism. They were reckless beasts that didn't know what they were, Absolutely lacking in generations of instinct. 

What questions do you want answered? Again you need to start a topic on this instead of bringing this comment everywhere. 

I think the underlying theme of all the hatred for anything other than our original Alien xeno comes from its diminishing status from movie to movie as an near Lovecraftian Elder God to its current status as a trainable smart cockroach.   Even Sir Ridley has contributed to its diminishing status by making it a bioweapon or the product of an AI experiment in the prequels.  What makes the xeno truly terrifying is thinking of it as some ancient beast laying dormant for millennia just waiting for someone to awaken it and then all hell breaks loose. 

All that being said there were things about Alien Earth that I did enjoy. I think there is potential for the new monsters in the future to wreck havoc.   I am a fan of all types of science fiction and horror so the human vs AI story line is also intriguing.  There has always been some speculation that AI or something other than human was pulling the strings behind the scenes in the Alien series so maybe one of the synthetics or maybe even the eyeball takes over (wouldn't that be fun).  

I think maybe (apart from the subjective viewpoint) the division between liking or disliking in general is due to generational differences. People, particularly sci-fi/horror fans who grew up watching the original films might prefer those for what they are and also in hindsight for nostalgic reasons, but I doubt people were as divided with the difference between Alien and Aliens as they are with Alien and Alien Earth for example. Ridley Scott and James Cameron are simply among the best directors (especially when they were young imo) and set the standard for Alien so high it's impossible to top, especially from the perspective of old schoolers.

I also think, and this is admittedly a rather bold statement, that there's truth to the matter that directors, writers and people overall back in the day were simply- with the lack of a better word, "smarter" in general as they really had to think themselves without the aid of countless computer applications doing the work for them. This applies to other areas as well such as piloting an aircraft without numerous assisting instruments.

With exceptions of course, applies to both then and now. 

Would like to see the writers kill off all the lost boys, with Wendy being the first to go because she's so evil. Then I would like to see all the way the aliens were captured and where they are from. Wouldn't anyone like to see a planet with all octopus eye monsters?

Or bullying people who are new to the forum or how it works yet.

It's hard to define what is disrespectful to fans at this point. The split opinions on this show and the common complaint that goes something like "Alien is ruined" is so well worn that the divide is unsurprising but you'll have fans say the exact thing about Aliens. James Cameron disrespected the original Alien by making them giant space bugs. Alien 3 disrespected fans by killing Hicks and Newt. Resurrection disrespected everyone by existing. Ridley Scott pissed on fans with Prometheus and Covenant. Fedè Alvarez insults fans intelligence with a safe dumb movie. Out of the Shadows was an insult by shoe horning Ripley in. AVP disrespect the xeno life cycle with accelerated gestation and births (now the normal oddly). Requiem exists. Alien Earth causing fans to riot feels like another day at the office. Absolutely nothing will satisfy everyone. I see just as many people excited about Romulus 2 as I see people disinterested. I see demands for the third prequel and an equal amount of apathy for that storyline to continue. I see want for Blomkamp's 5 to be resurrected and people happy it was canceled. Earth is already the same. People want a season 2 and people want it canceled. Just Another day at the office.

Very true, it's all subjective. I guess if we all agreed on everything there'd be no points to forums like these 😂

It's hard to define what is disrespectful to fans at this point. The split opinions on this show and the common complaint that goes something like "Alien is ruined" is so well worn that the divide is unsurprising but you'll have fans say the exact thing about Aliens. James Cameron disrespected the original Alien by making them giant space bugs. Alien 3 disrespected fans by killing Hicks and Newt. Resurrection disrespected everyone by existing. Ridley Scott pissed on fans with Prometheus and Covenant. Fedè Alvarez insults fans intelligence with a safe dumb movie. Out of the Shadows was an insult by shoe horning Ripley in. AVP disrespect the xeno life cycle with accelerated gestation and births (now the normal oddly). Requiem exists. Alien Earth causing fans to riot feels like another day at the office. Absolutely nothing will satisfy everyone. I see just as many people excited about Romulus 2 as I see people disinterested. I see demands for the third prequel and an equal amount of apathy for that storyline to continue. I see want for Blomkamp's 5 to be resurrected and people happy it was canceled. Earth is already the same. People want a season 2 and people want it canceled. Just Another day at the office.

The alien in this film has so many issues that took away the fear out of the show. The issues I noticed were as follows:  the alien looks dry not a shiny slew of slim others had to them in previous films and features. The suit bunches up by the thighs in multiple scenes making it look like “creature feature” with a thick stubby neck that makes the creature less intimidating and not more muscular. The color of the alien is off as brown and not black making it look less scary and man made. The mechanical upper jaw looks stiff giving the overall appeal of the alien as a puppeteer.
​

Overall, when pertaining to the alien design concept, Alien, Aliens, and Alien 3 had the best designs hands down. Just stick to the original design already for what works and is scary! Period. If you want a home run then plan, prepare, and play the game for one.

Next, fear is was drives this franchise. Use more scenes of isolation, and cleverness of where is the alien hiding that were used in the front half of the show. If Wendy can talk to these xenomorphs okay, well, with two xenomorphs in the picture as a community of organisms is she the mother of aliens representing the hive mind, or outcast from the hive as humans? The other creatures are just relatable concepts. True horror is originality unknown to men kind never seen before. Isn’t that what makes xenomorphs and predator scary? 
​

The storyline is overall good and shot well, but these key points need work. Get it together with the xenomorph. I found myself never scared for the first time.

How come my picture keeps disappearing?

You keep uploading a profile pic that’s identical to another member’s on the site and it can lead to confusion so it keeps getting rejected. Please upload a different photo not used by another member currently! Check your inbox, I sent you a private message about it.

Are they ever going to get their stories straight? Are they ever going to answer questions in the movies and shows and stop making the fans wait years without even getting an answer?

The whole Wendy storyline is pathetic. It has to go. The boy genius could have any storyline and be interesting. Wendy who wants to be called Marcy and then Wendy and then to rule, LOL! needs to go. The focus should be on the monsters. How come Ripley knew nothing about the Earth being attacked by monsters before her trip?

How come my picture keeps disappearing?

Kill Wendy and the lost boys and I will give this horrible show a 2nd chance.

I hope the boy genius isn't a robot.

"Try Harder" – yes please. I hope for season 2 they bring on new writers that, I found that to be my biggest gripe. So many open ends and inconsistencies. I also feel the cast was too large, keeping it more intimate make the deaths more impactful. None of the main characters died... Literally everyone is still there at the end.

I also agree it felt very B-movie but I took it a bit more personal, to me it felt very disrespectful. Scott and Giger created a masterful beast and atmosphere that's inspired countless stories and films since. James Cameron wanted to give his own take on it but still respected the source material and adapted his ideas in a tasteful, respectful way. Noah Hawley literally said he sees the Xenomorph as a cockroach... a cockroach?! Gtfo 

I desperately wanted to enjoy this show and there were moments I did enjoy, set pieces, Morrow and Kirsh being about it. T. Ocellus as well – saved it in some ways. But overall it felt like a complete disregard for our intelligence as viewers and disrespect for our beloved franchise as fans. 

First, I’m an OG Alien fan. I saw Ridley Scott’s “Alien” in 1979, on my 20th birthday, and it was a game changer. Mixing horror with SciFi was brilliant. Fast forward to 2025. The storyline was good, not great. I enjoyed the premise of different alien species being collected. The one thing that didn’t sit well with me was a synthetic being able to communicate with a Xenomorph, almost “pet like”. I will rewatch this again over the winter, but it’s not something I’d purchase in physical media form. When I really, really enjoy something, it’s added to my 4K and Bluray collections. This will not be.

Agreed – I enjoyed the expansion of alien species and the attempt at diving deeper into Weyland-Yutani lore, but the execution was fumbled by horrible writing and sub-par acting, having children inhabit Synth bodies was a mistake imo. The best episode in the series was Episode 5 and it's cause there were no children Synths and it took place on a familiar looking ship and borrowed heavily from what worked in Alien.

Overall I expected more and have no intention of ever adding this to my collection, sadly. I really wanted to like it, kept holding out that the finale would deliver. I was disappointed.

You're correct, Hawley favors a synth story line above all else. You'll either enjoy it or hate it. There's not much in between on this one. It definitely feels like the reception is more positive than Covenant and even Prometheus but much like them, those that hate it really hate it. Overall it's another highly divisive Alien entry. Pretty normal at this rate lol. I'm curious how people will feel about it ten years down the line especially if it doesn't get a second season. 

Interesting, I haven't watched it since I don't have the channel where it's on. Unfortunately it seems like a lot of it is about androids and I'm not interested in that. Maybe I would prefer it over the prequels if I would watch it, it's possible.

First, I’m an OG Alien fan. I saw Ridley Scott’s “Alien” in 1979, on my 20th birthday, and it was a game changer. Mixing horror with SciFi was brilliant. Fast forward to 2025. The storyline was good, not great. I enjoyed the premise of different alien species being collected. The one thing that didn’t sit well with me was a synthetic being able to communicate with a Xenomorph, almost “pet like”. I will rewatch this again over the winter, but it’s not something I’d purchase in physical media form. When I really, really enjoy something, it’s added to my 4K and Bluray collections. This will not be. 

The series was retarded.  It never should have seen the light of day.

I could have sworn I saw something like this in one of the Alien movies.

They're the happy little animals in Wendy’s new Disneyland resort 😂

Why wasn't there a choice for HATED IT!?

He looks and stands like a human. If not for the head, you would think the character was human.

Hope we saw the last of the lemon sucking "captain".

Wendy and Her? xenomorph. How ridiculous!

🚨 Rant Warning 🚨

I tried to like it, to look past all the glaring issues, the horrible writing and the painstaking stupidity among the characters. To see something so utterly amazing I'd forget all this just for the moment. Only, there was nothing. No real interesting characters, no sense of dread, no convincing threat, no tension, no adrenaline and no compelling drama whatsoever. A Xenomorph that's practically stripped of all its terror which in itself dragged the show down considerably. Endless useless citations to Peter Pan's adventures and symbolism that never hits the mark because nothing is ever engaging to begin with, and throwbacks and references to the older films sprinkled all over it like a bunch of confectioners who fail so miserably at baking cakes but try to cover it up with half-hearted toppings. It's inedible. A complete cringefest. I would even....

*inhales..... exhales*

WoULd eVen...

*Starts convulsing*

Recommend Prometheus over this. Yep I said it. 

"He's right behind me, isn't he?"

"He knows you know Zoya..."

And yeah, Wendy has been given way too much power and control over things. A character like this is never entertaining to watch. She as a character is interesting in few episodes but the script was not creative enough. Cheesy phrases and grunge/metal music at the end does not help also.
​

Very very poor ending. I had hopes till episode 5. Then it all collapsed because the script was basically garbage. Kirsh as one the key players, intelligent as he was portrayed in first episodes, was an character that could've been more misterious and I was expecting him to have his agenda/deal with WY, but they went really cheap and cheesy. He was way way too naive and stupid in the finale, like it was not him. So the script is very contradicting as well imho.

Xenomorph as a dog does not work. Like wth, seriously?

I just hope we get to see Ridley do his movie to end Davids story. 

It's way too big to be David, Daniels, or any human.

Glad the eye is out of the sheep. What were those 3 points on it's head that laid down after the sheep got eyed?