Fire Question on LV223
Prometheus Forum Topic
Promethian Man
MemberOvomorphJune 06, 20121518 Views12 RepliesOkay, so this isn't a nitpick, just a question for you science buffs out there - the atmosphere of LV223 is not breathable we know that from all of the crew having to wear space suits on the surface.
Yet, when Vickers cooks Holloway outside the ship with the flamethrower, he burns pretty furiously, and the flamethrower obviously spouts out copious amounts of fire. But doesn't that mean there is plentiful oxygen in the air? Doesn't fire need oxygen to burn?
Any answers?
Other discussions started by Promethian Man
Replies to Fire Question on LV223
Hadley's HopeJune 06, 2012
It wasn't a LACK of oxygen, but a high concentration of Carbon Monoxide that made the air unbreathable. 

CypherJune 06, 2012
And fire only needs about .2 percent oxygen to burn in any atmosphere
[url=http://www.robocopmovie.net/][img]http://i888.photobucket.com/albums/ac89/snorkelbottom/NewRoboBanner.jpg[/img][/url]
"Is it dead this time?" "I dunno, poke it with this stick and see."
Promethian ManJune 06, 2012
Okay sure, that's plausible enough - which part of the film did they mention that? I want to look that up again, thanks.

Hadley's HopeJune 06, 2012
When they were arriving on the planet someone is describing the atmosphere. I think it was the doctor, but it was far too uninteresting to recall exactly who said it. I do recall that it was mentioned you wouldn't last more than 3 minutes without a helmet.
Promethian ManJune 06, 2012
@Hadley's Hope,
Yeah, I recall - it was the Scottish woman I think, she said you'd last about 2 minutes...

Xenomorph 54June 06, 2012
@Hadley's Hope and Promethian Man
 
It was Ravel (the co-pilot) that described the atmosphere.
Have you heard of phoenix asteroids?
They glow in every color of the rainbow...they travel endlessly through space...
Indy JohnJanuary 07, 2013
  So in reading over the posts  there seems to be scientic evidence that fire can be used on the surface of the moon.  But based on the breakdown of the atmosphere would fire as we know it on earth  be burning in the same fashion  and quantity that we are familiar with?
 I watching the scenes after Juggernaut crash  while Shaw was running to the shuttle and spised a bit at the number of fires throughout the scene  with some examples  even into the hills.
  Couldthe fires be larger or smaller than on earth  given the same material?  Could the atmoshere explode as an atomic bomb  because of the contents of the atmosphere.
 I guess  if the moon's atmosphere is different than Earth's  how would the fire as seen by the crew be different  if at all.
  if there are indeed vast differences this would lead more to the 'everything is a dream' that we are seeing on the screen   Making us wonder just who is dreaming and what is real.
  I just wanted a clearer scientific  understanding of the fire we see depicted in the movie.
Be choicelessly aware as you move through life
javablueJanuary 07, 2013
According to Ravel there was 21% oxygen in the moon's atmosphere. That's the same as earth. No probs with fire but Ravel left out a whopping 8% of the atmosphere. Another blunder.
Ford pipes up and says there's 3% CO2 (why didn't Ravel mention that?). Three percent CO2 won't kill you in a few minutes - you could stay alive for a long time in only 3%.
Of course, it seems Ford was confusing CO2 with carbon monoxide given the mention of the tailpipe. Another mistake. 
Probably doesn't mean anything though. Just another writer error....
Indy JohnJanuary 10, 2013
Thanks for some explanation of the fire numbers.  I was just glad that  if based on the actual numbers,  the moon would explode into flames once ignited.
  If the atmosphere was a fire hazard  then just the Prometheus landing would have caused problems.
 Actually i thinking back  to the flyover  there was nothing to burn(in an earth sense)  I didn't see any forest/woods/trees   or even grass that could be fuel.
   It seemed to me that the surface of this moon was covered  if not by vapor cloud then it must have been smoke.
  But with fuel for burning   and seemingly  very lkittle surface water..just how did  all of the clouds form?
  What is the clouds  composition? I mean if it is not water vapor  and it's not smoke  what is left?..
  
Be choicelessly aware as you move through life



