Forum Topic

TheNextLV426
MemberOvomorphApr-08-2012 4:52 PMI didn't see this posted already. Apologies if it missed it (I did search)
Damon Lindelof, Prometheus screen written discusses the nature of prequals and Prometheus.
As I have said all along, Prometheus does not end with Alien. That would leave the Prometheus franchise with very little opportunity to evolve.
......
The thing about a prequel is, as fascinating as it may to watch Anakin turn to the dark side of the Force, there's an inevitability to it. You know when you go in the prequel can only cover A to Y and then Z is gonna be the preexisting material. You can't end it in an exciting or surprising way. You can only end it in the inevitable way. ...
When I went to go see The Thing prequel, for example, I'm assuming this movie is going to be the sequence of events that led up to a dog being infected by the Thing and then being chased by a helicopter across the frozen tundra-because I know then what happens next because I saw The Thing. And that's exactly what it was. On a certain level, you're satisfied because if you're calling a movie a prequel, that's what you're expecting. On another level, you sort of walk out going, "Boy I wish there was a little bit more room for me to not exactly know what I was walking into."
In my opinion, in order to define Prometheus as a prequel, is it set in the Alien universe? ... If you just watch the teaser trailer, and you see how the word Prometheus reveals itself ... or look at the production design, you don't need me to tell you anything.
So then the next question is: Is it a prequel to Alien? To that, I can't really answer the question because my definition of prequel, the A-to-Y definition, I hope it's not. I hope that this movie can be surprising. The ending of this movie; the sequel to Prometheus is not Alien. The sequel to Prometheus, if it does well and people like it, would be another movie that goes off in its own direction, that runs tangential to Alien.
6 Replies

thefacehead
MemberOvomorphApr-08-2012 5:07 PMTo be fair George Lucas doesn't know what he's doing (unless you talk about making money then he clearly does lol) but this is Sir Ridders and he does know what he's doing! There are a million possibilities with this prequel as oppose to Star Wars (yes he could have done it better, my cat had better plots) because he was limited. Ridders is not limited here, he has the Alien world at his feet. Weyland Industries is an endless world to be explored and their interest in bio weapons is also endless, whose to say it was just the 'Alien' they were chasing? The whole point is that we are all excited to be speculating and as fans of Alien are very lucky to have this opportunity unlike fans of Indiana Jones or Dare I say it but Star Wars who have been horribly scarred for life!

Forever War
MemberOvomorphApr-08-2012 5:31 PM@TheNextLV426 ---- I think for this film to be labeled from the beginning as an "Alien" prequel was a necessary evil, so to speak. It raised expectations that may not be addressed to the satisfaction of many, but for marketing purposes it was deemed the best way to reach the public. I agree with your assessments and definitions and I have to wonder how many hardcore fans are going to change the views they have built internally when the rating is finally announced. That should give us some fresh discussion and rants to fill the time remaining before it's release.

pol III
MemberOvomorphApr-08-2012 8:32 PMExerpt from a new R. Scott interview:
"One does not simply make an Alien prequel."

Mafetu
MemberOvomorphApr-08-2012 9:15 PMInitially I wanted Prometheus to be a perfect prequel. Now I am coming around to the idea expressed by Mr. Lindelof.
Admittedly this is not a good example but I hated the way the prequel to The Thing felt it necessary to tie up every visual and did so in such a forced, contrived way.
Necrofan
MemberOvomorphApr-09-2012 11:43 AMAs I have said before, in my opinion, a prequel- in its literal definition of the genre- is very much confining to a writer/director who have an original, stand-alone movie franchise they want to produce.

george74
MemberOvomorphJul-03-2012 3:25 AMRather than being a concept distinct from that of a sequel, a prequel still adheres to the general principle of serialization, defined only by its internal chronology and publication order.
Add A Reply
Join the discussion! Sign in using your Scified Account to add your say!
New to the site? You can create your own profile in seconds!
* Signing in also removes ads *